Surface Book 2From real comments

Verdict distilled from 49 mentions across 16 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment71%
PROS 71%
CONS 29%

Rank based on 49 mentions across 16 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want a detachable tablet/laptop hybrid for drawing, note-taking and presentations
  • You need real gaming or GPU-accelerated creative performance (video editing, 3D, Adobe apps) in a portable form
  • You value premium build quality and Microsoft's strong support/warranty experience

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You need Thunderbolt 3 support for external GPUs or high-speed peripherals
  • You're on a tight budget, since the GTX 1050/1060 configurations get expensive fast
  • You want guaranteed all-day battery life, as several users report far less than advertised

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Premium
Great for creative and technical professionalsUnique detachable tablet + GPU form factorDetachable screen and hinge design loved by usersHigh price relative to specsPen jitter and lack of pen tech improvementThick bezels and lack of design refresh
Great for creative and technical professionals
Unique detachable tablet + GPU form factor
Detachable screen and hinge design loved by users
High price relative to specs
Pen jitter and lack of pen tech improvement
Thick bezels and lack of design refresh
2Premium
True Windows OS beats iPad for real work
True Windows OS beats iPad for real work
You are here
3Premium
Surface Book 2
Great for creative professional workStrong GPU for its sizeVersatile 2-in-1 form factorHigh priceNo Thunderbolt 3 supportProprietary charger / USB-C charging confusion
Surface Book 2
Great for creative professional work
Strong GPU for its size
Versatile 2-in-1 form factor
High price
No Thunderbolt 3 support
Proprietary charger / USB-C charging confusion
4Premium
Innovative, polished build qualitySeamless foldable 18-inch displayHarmonyOS speed and ecosystem connectivityHigh price limits accessibilityMissing essential apps outside ChinaWindows runs only as a virtualized VM
Innovative, polished build quality
Seamless foldable 18-inch display
HarmonyOS speed and ecosystem connectivity
High price limits accessibility
Missing essential apps outside China
Windows runs only as a virtualized VM
Best value
5Budget
Major performance upgrade over original DuetGreat for travel and portabilityLong ChromeOS software supportNo headphone jackUncomfortable kickstand in tablet modeWeak or problematic speakers
Major performance upgrade over original Duet
Great for travel and portability
Long ChromeOS software support
No headphone jack
Uncomfortable kickstand in tablet mode
Weak or problematic speakers
6Mid
Solid Build & Hinge Quality
Solid Build & Hinge Quality
7Premium
Versatile 2-in-1 for creative workCapable GPU in a thin form factorLong-term reliability and durabilityBattery and GPU connection failures over timeHigh price relative to alternativesConfusing USB-C charging support
Versatile 2-in-1 for creative work
Capable GPU in a thin form factor
Long-term reliability and durability
Battery and GPU connection failures over time
High price relative to alternatives
Confusing USB-C charging support
8Premium
Capable iGPU and dGPU for its sizeStrong battery lifeExceptional portabilityRAM capped unless buying top configThermal throttling in flat/laptop modeBuild quality and durability issues
Capable iGPU and dGPU for its size
Strong battery life
Exceptional portability
RAM capped unless buying top config
Thermal throttling in flat/laptop mode
Build quality and durability issues
9Mid
Strong price-to-performance valueFast, fluid performanceComfortable backlit keyboardInconsistent battery lifeBase RAM/storage limitationsBase model dim, low-color display
Strong price-to-performance value
Fast, fluid performance
Comfortable backlit keyboard
Inconsistent battery life
Base RAM/storage limitations
Base model dim, low-color display
10Mid
Good for productivity multitaskingPortability and light weightRuns full Windows, not just appsUnderpowered base RAM and storageHigh price once keyboard and upgrades are addedBattery life only adequate
Good for productivity multitasking
Portability and light weight
Runs full Windows, not just apps
Underpowered base RAM and storage
High price once keyboard and upgrades are added
Battery life only adequate

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

A genuinely versatile hybrid with no direct competitor. Commenters repeatedly describe using the Surface Book 2 across normal laptop mode, flipped 'easel' mode for drawing, and full tablet mode for notes and presentations. Users highlight that it replaces both a MacBook and an iPad Pro, or a laptop plus a separate Wacom drawing tablet, since the pen and touchscreen are built in. Reviewers say no other device combines gaming-capable GPU, detachability, and pen input in one machine.

Surprisingly strong GPU and creative performance for its size. Multiple commenters are impressed that a 13-inch device packs a GTX 1050 or 1060, calling it 'insane' and 'nutty' for the form factor. Owners report running Premiere Pro, Maya, ZBrush, Blender and 3DS Max, plus casual and serious gaming, with one professional video editor calling it a true 'pro' laptop worth the cost for demanding creative workloads.

Price and missing Thunderbolt 3 are the main sticking points. Many commenters justify the roughly $3000 price by comparing specs and features favorably to the MacBook Pro, citing better keyboard, battery, GPU and touch functionality. Still, several call it expensive or a hard sell, and multiple technically-minded commenters explain the lack of Thunderbolt 3 is due to CPU PCIe lane limits, which some flag as a real dealbreaker despite otherwise strong value.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?