Xiaomi 17 UltraFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 44 mentions across 13 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment69%
PROS 69%
CONS 31%

Rank based on 44 mentions across 13 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want the best zoom and low-light camera on a phone
  • You enjoy manual photography controls like ISO, shutter and the camera ring
  • You value Leica color science over flat, processed smartphone shots

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You want simple point-and-shoot photos without learning camera settings
  • You need full-resolution RAW files across all lenses
  • You dislike Xiaomi's HyperOS software experience

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Mid
Samsung Galaxy S10~$900 · 1.8× cheaper
Headphone Jack RetainedGenerous Specs (RAM/Storage)No-Notch Hole-Punch DisplayHigh PriceUnnecessary Bixby ButtonConfusing Plus Model Differentiation
Samsung Galaxy S10~$900 · 1.8× cheaper
Headphone Jack Retained
Generous Specs (RAM/Storage)
No-Notch Hole-Punch Display
High Price
Unnecessary Bixby Button
Confusing Plus Model Differentiation
Best value
2Upper
Xiaomi 17 Pro~$1,200 · 1.3× cheaper
Versatile rear displayLong-term reliability from loyal usersGenuine innovation despite Apple comparisonsDesign closely mirrors AppleSome rear-screen features are region-limitedAluminum frame scratches easily
Xiaomi 17 Pro~$1,200 · 1.3× cheaper
Versatile rear display
Long-term reliability from loyal users
Genuine innovation despite Apple comparisons
Design closely mirrors Apple
Some rear-screen features are region-limited
Aluminum frame scratches easily
3Upper
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra~$1,300 · 1.2× cheaper
Useful Galaxy AI featuresFlat anti-reflective displayLong software support (7 years)Incremental upgrade for recent Ultra ownersLost legacy hardware featuresRegional chipset differences
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra~$1,300 · 1.2× cheaper
Useful Galaxy AI features
Flat anti-reflective display
Long software support (7 years)
Incremental upgrade for recent Ultra owners
Lost legacy hardware features
Regional chipset differences
4Mid
Samsung Galaxy Note 8~$930 · 1.7× cheaper
Overall satisfaction / best phone ownedS Pen functionalityValue deals and discountsInconsistent battery lifeHigh original priceCould use more RAM
Samsung Galaxy Note 8~$930 · 1.7× cheaper
Overall satisfaction / best phone owned
S Pen functionality
Value deals and discounts
Inconsistent battery life
High original price
Could use more RAM
5Mid
LG V60~$899 · 1.8× cheaper
Quad DAC audio quality3.5mm headphone jack retainedBattery lifeBulky size and comfortDiscontinued product lineFlat 60Hz display seen as dated
LG V60~$899 · 1.8× cheaper
Quad DAC audio quality
3.5mm headphone jack retained
Battery life
Bulky size and comfort
Discontinued product line
Flat 60Hz display seen as dated
6Upper
Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra~$1,200 · 1.3× cheaper
Excellent battery lifeS-Pen functionalitySmooth switch from iPhoneHigh price with fewer inclusionsSparse in-box accessories and packaging10x zoom lens limitations
Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra~$1,200 · 1.3× cheaper
Excellent battery life
S-Pen functionality
Smooth switch from iPhone
High price with fewer inclusions
Sparse in-box accessories and packaging
10x zoom lens limitations
7Mid
LG V50~$999 · 1.6× cheaper
Quad DAC audio qualityHeadphone jack retainedLong-term reliabilityDated chipset and limited software updatesHigh launch price due to 5GDual Screen accessory adds bulk
LG V50~$999 · 1.6× cheaper
Quad DAC audio quality
Headphone jack retained
Long-term reliability
Dated chipset and limited software updates
High launch price due to 5G
Dual Screen accessory adds bulk
8Mid
Samsung Galaxy Note 9~$1,000 · 1.6× cheaper
Feature-complete package (S Pen, DeX, headphone jack, IP68)Excellent battery lifeGood value versus competitorsHigh price perceptionApp loading stutters on Exynos variantBixby button dissatisfaction
Samsung Galaxy Note 9~$1,000 · 1.6× cheaper
Feature-complete package (S Pen, DeX, headphone jack, IP68)
Excellent battery life
Good value versus competitors
High price perception
App loading stutters on Exynos variant
Bixby button dissatisfaction
9Mid
Google Pixel 8 Pro~$999 · 1.6× cheaper
Seven years of software supportExcellent camera and zoomImproved battery lifePro-exclusive features frustrate buyersPerformance stutters and lagCamera lens switching lag in video
Google Pixel 8 Pro~$999 · 1.6× cheaper
Seven years of software support
Excellent camera and zoom
Improved battery life
Pro-exclusive features frustrate buyers
Performance stutters and lag
Camera lens switching lag in video
10Upper
Huawei Mate 30 Pro~$1,200 · 1.3× cheaper
Unlocked Bootloader Enables Google WorkaroundsExceptional Camera & Video FeaturesOverall Innovation & Best-in-Class ReputationUS Ban & Regional Availability IssuesNo Google Play Services Out of the BoxVolume Control Complaints
Huawei Mate 30 Pro~$1,200 · 1.3× cheaper
Unlocked Bootloader Enables Google Workarounds
Exceptional Camera & Video Features
Overall Innovation & Best-in-Class Reputation
US Ban & Regional Availability Issues
No Google Play Services Out of the Box
Volume Control Complaints
You are here
14Upper
Xiaomi 17 Ultra~$1,600
Exceptional camera and zoom qualityLeica color science and natural renderingManual camera controls and physical ringCapped RAW resolution despite high-MP marketingHyperOS software holds back the experienceLost telephoto macro lens from previous Ultra models
Xiaomi 17 Ultra~$1,600
Exceptional camera and zoom quality
Leica color science and natural rendering
Manual camera controls and physical ring
Capped RAW resolution despite high-MP marketing
HyperOS software holds back the experience
Lost telephoto macro lens from previous Ultra models

Who wins on what (similar price)

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

The camera hardware impresses almost everyone who tries it, especially the telephoto and low-light performance. Commenters repeatedly praise the Xiaomi 17 Ultra's camera as superior to iPhones and Samsung flagships, citing sharp moon shots, clean night photos, and impressive portrait and B&W output. The telephoto lens with real optical zoom and low noise stood out, and Leica Authentic/Vibrant color profiles were called more realistic than competitors. Multiple owners said it rivaled dedicated Leica and Fujifilm cameras for everyday photography use.

RAW shooting is limited to about 12.5MP despite the 50MP/200MP sensor marketing, frustrating enthusiasts. Several users found that RAW files from the main and telephoto cameras cap around 12.5MP instead of the advertised 50MP/200MP, making the sensors effectively lower-resolution for RAW workflows. JPEG quality also degraded at higher resolutions. Users requested firmware updates to unlock full-resolution RAW and 50MP pro-mode shooting across all lenses, including cropped focal lengths like 28-46mm.

The phone rewards photographers who understand manual controls, but punishes casual point-and-shoot users. Multiple commenters stressed that getting the best results requires understanding exposure, ISO, and shutter speed, unlike the 'idiot-proof' flat images from iPhone or Samsung. The camera ring and optional grip accessory were loved for creating a true camera-like experience, though the lack of a physical shutter button and rotating-bezel case compatibility were noted drawbacks for casual users.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?