Synology DS1512From real comments

Verdict distilled from 21 mentions across 7 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment11%
PROS 11%
CONS 89%

Rank based on 21 mentions across 7 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You need flexible RAID/SHR expansion across multiple drives
  • You want a NAS that can hit full gigabit ethernet speeds once properly networked
  • You are comfortable diagnosing and soldering DOM or PSU hardware faults yourself

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You are not prepared to eventually deal with DOM chip or capacitor failures
  • You cannot afford a $230+ out-of-warranty repair if the unit fails to boot
  • You expect drives included at the roughly $900 purchase price

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Mid
Easy setup and intuitive DSM software
Easy setup and intuitive DSM software
2Mid
Easy setup for beginners
Easy setup for beginners
3Mid
Long-term reliabilityNetworking speed beyond 1GbpsPlex and media handling improved by SSD cacheFan noiseCPU thermal and virtualization limitsMixed value of RAM/SSD upgrades for basic use
Long-term reliability
Networking speed beyond 1Gbps
Plex and media handling improved by SSD cache
Fan noise
CPU thermal and virtualization limits
Mixed value of RAM/SSD upgrades for basic use
4Premium
Expandable storage capacityReliability and data recoveryEase of use / DSM interfaceDrive compatibility alerts and vendor lock-inWeak Plex transcodingExpensive proprietary RAM
Expandable storage capacity
Reliability and data recovery
Ease of use / DSM interface
Drive compatibility alerts and vendor lock-in
Weak Plex transcoding
Expensive proprietary RAM
5
Bus-Powered FlexibilityCompact, Portable DesignDrives Readable If Enclosure FailsNoisy Drive ActivityAbrupt Unmount SoundRAID 1 Doesn't Boost Read Speed
Bus-Powered Flexibility
Compact, Portable Design
Drives Readable If Enclosure Fails
Noisy Drive Activity
Abrupt Unmount Sound
RAID 1 Doesn't Boost Read Speed
Best value
6Budget
Sufficient for backups, streaming, and surveillanceEasy setup for beginnersGood value versus higher-tier modelsNo drive redundancyConfusing entry-level lineup overlapMissing vibration dampers
Sufficient for backups, streaming, and surveillance
Easy setup for beginners
Good value versus higher-tier models
No drive redundancy
Confusing entry-level lineup overlap
Missing vibration dampers
7Mid
Great for Time Machine and photo backupLong-term reliabilitySolid upgrade from older/competing NASRAID is not a backupDrive/component lock-in and costNoise and power draw
Great for Time Machine and photo backup
Long-term reliability
Solid upgrade from older/competing NAS
RAID is not a backup
Drive/component lock-in and cost
Noise and power draw
8Mid
Dual 10GbE and Thunderbolt connectivityStrong hardware for the priceExpandable and third-party OS friendlySoftware stability issuesFan noise at idleNVMe/PCIe lane limitations
Dual 10GbE and Thunderbolt connectivity
Strong hardware for the price
Expandable and third-party OS friendly
Software stability issues
Fan noise at idle
NVMe/PCIe lane limitations
9Premium
Flexible RAID and third-party OS supportStrong hardware specs vs competitorsCapable for video editing workflowsInconsistent idle fan noiseUGOS software immaturityReal-world transfer speed issues
Flexible RAID and third-party OS support
Strong hardware specs vs competitors
Capable for video editing workflows
Inconsistent idle fan noise
UGOS software immaturity
Real-world transfer speed issues
10Premium
Highly expandable hardwareHigh throughput with 10GbE and cacheStrong VM and app supportNo hardware transcoding for 4KConfusing cache setup guidanceConsumer NVMe cache reliability risk
Highly expandable hardware
High throughput with 10GbE and cache
Strong VM and app support
No hardware transcoding for 4K
Confusing cache setup guidance
Consumer NVMe cache reliability risk
You are here
31Premium
Synology DS1512
Gigabit ethernet networking capabilityProfessional design and build appearanceWidespread DOM (Disk On Module) boot failuresPower supply and capacitor failuresInconsistent or slow transfer speeds
Synology DS1512
Gigabit ethernet networking capability
Professional design and build appearance
Widespread DOM (Disk On Module) boot failures
Power supply and capacitor failures
Inconsistent or slow transfer speeds

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Boot failures from a defective DOM chip are the most frequently reported issue. Numerous commenters describe the same symptom: a continuously blinking blue light and repeated boot cycling, most often traced to a failed DOM (Disk On Module) chip rather than the drives themselves. Users across different threads mention swapping the DOM, reprogramming it, or replacing the onboard controller after a power outage or over time. One person mentions the fault reaching Australia and helping them save a 10-disk RAID array, showing how widespread this specific failure pattern is among long-term owners of this unit.

Power supply and capacitor quality concerns compound the reliability worries. Beyond the DOM, several users found hardware-level faults tied to the power supply, including a visibly bulged capacitor and a dead CMOS cell on the motherboard. One person speculated their power supply itself was bad after a boot failure, while another criticized Seasonic for switching to cheap capacitors instead of the brand's usual quality parts. Another commenter simply asked why boards look burnt, suggesting these capacitor and power issues are a recurring theme for some units.

RAID flexibility and network throughput satisfy some users despite the hardware complaints. Interest in the unit's storage flexibility appears in questions about expanding SHR-1 or RAID 5 arrays with additional drives without data loss, and one commenter called the unit's design professional and nice-looking. Another explained that the DS1512+ can handle full gigabit ethernet speeds, though bottlenecks often come from a user's router or network card rather than the NAS itself. Repair costs and no-drives-included pricing around $900 were still noted as drawbacks.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?