Phase One XF IQ4From real comments

Verdict distilled from 18 mentions across 11 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment35%
PROS 35%
CONS 65%

Rank based on 18 mentions across 11 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You need the absolute highest resolution medium format look money can buy
  • You're already invested in the Phase One system and value its handling and back quality
  • Budget is no object, including a high-end computer to process the files

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You're put off by reports of unreliable performance and single-point autofocus
  • You don't want to pay extra for a powerful computer just to handle the huge files
  • You'd rather have modern mirrorless tech and weather sealing, like the Fuji GFX

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Mid
Phase One IQ150~$23,990 · 1.9× cheaper
Beautiful skin tonesClassic CCD lookMedium format rendering and dynamic rangeAutofocus weaker for people photographyPost-processing didn't match camera's level
Phase One IQ150~$23,990 · 1.9× cheaper
Beautiful skin tones
Classic CCD look
Medium format rendering and dynamic range
Autofocus weaker for people photography
Post-processing didn't match camera's level
2Upper
Phase One IQ4~$39,990 · similar price
Exceptional detail and resolutionOutstanding dynamic range and colorFrame averaging featureExtremely high total costLimited movements on some body variantsDebatable image quality edge over rivals
Phase One IQ4~$39,990 · similar price
Exceptional detail and resolution
Outstanding dynamic range and color
Frame averaging feature
Extremely high total cost
Limited movements on some body variants
Debatable image quality edge over rivals
3Mid
Phase One P45~$29,990 · 1.5× cheaper
Excellent color and image qualityCommon battery compatibilityOngoing manufacturer servicingCostly repairsHardware reliability issueHigh overall system cost
Phase One P45~$29,990 · 1.5× cheaper
Excellent color and image quality
Common battery compatibility
Ongoing manufacturer servicing
Costly repairs
Hardware reliability issue
High overall system cost
4Upper
Phase One XT IQ4~$56,990 · 1.3× pricier
Exceptional detail and image qualityOutstanding dynamic range and colorTrusted, long-term workhorse for professionalsNo tilt or swing movementVery high price relative to outputLimited lens selection
Phase One XT IQ4~$56,990 · 1.3× pricier
Exceptional detail and image quality
Outstanding dynamic range and color
Trusted, long-term workhorse for professionals
No tilt or swing movement
Very high price relative to output
Limited lens selection
5Mid
Phase One XF IQ3~$33,990 · 1.3× cheaper
Wireless tethering supportHigh-resolution 100MP backModular system designAutofocus system concernsCheap-feeling build qualityNo vertical grip for portrait shooting
Phase One XF IQ3~$33,990 · 1.3× cheaper
Wireless tethering support
High-resolution 100MP back
Modular system design
Autofocus system concerns
Cheap-feeling build quality
No vertical grip for portrait shooting
6Upper
Phase One IQ4 150MP~$51,990 · 1.2× pricier
Exceptional ResolutionDesirable Dream Camera StatusImpressive Image QualityCropping Doesn't Replace Longer LensesHigh Price BarrierLimited Video Capability
Phase One IQ4 150MP~$51,990 · 1.2× pricier
Exceptional Resolution
Desirable Dream Camera Status
Impressive Image Quality
Cropping Doesn't Replace Longer Lenses
High Price Barrier
Limited Video Capability
You are here
7Upper
Phase One XF IQ4~$44,990
Exceptional 150MP resolutionDistinctive medium format lookGreat handling and buildExtremely high total costQuestionable necessity of 150MPReliability concerns
Phase One XF IQ4~$44,990
Exceptional 150MP resolution
Distinctive medium format look
Great handling and build
Extremely high total cost
Questionable necessity of 150MP
Reliability concerns
8Upper
Phase One XC IQ4~$61,490 · 1.4× pricier
Exceptional resolution and detailCompact form factor vs alternativesStrong system reputation and buyer enthusiasmUnclear value versus the XT systemVery high price relative to alternativesNo shift or tilt capability
Phase One XC IQ4~$61,490 · 1.4× pricier
Exceptional resolution and detail
Compact form factor vs alternatives
Strong system reputation and buyer enthusiasm
Unclear value versus the XT system
Very high price relative to alternatives
No shift or tilt capability
9Upper
Phase One P65~$39,990 · similar price
Strong sensor qualityCold flash white balanceMagenta cast in overexposed highlights
Phase One P65~$39,990 · similar price
Strong sensor quality
Cold flash white balance
Magenta cast in overexposed highlights
10Mid
Phase One IQ3~$28,990 · 1.6× cheaper
Exceptional Detail and SharpnessGrowing Lens EcosystemWireless Tethering SupportVery High PriceAutofocus LimitationsLimited Depth of Field Sharpness
Phase One IQ3~$28,990 · 1.6× cheaper
Exceptional Detail and Sharpness
Growing Lens Ecosystem
Wireless Tethering Support
Very High Price
Autofocus Limitations
Limited Depth of Field Sharpness

Who wins on what (similar price)

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Medium format image quality that long-time users call groundbreaking. A Phase One user since 2009 describes the XF as fantastic after multiple generations of upgrades, calling each one groundbreaking in its moment. Others echo the excitement over 150 megapixels, describing the resolution as crazy and amazing, and praising the fantastic feel in the hand along with the lenses and backs, saying there's nothing like the medium format look these files produce.

The price tag extends far beyond the body itself. Commenters repeatedly stress that the camera's cost is only the beginning, noting you'd need to tack on $5,000-10,000 for a computer powerful enough to render and store the gigabyte-size files, with one estimating a maxed-out workstation pushes the total system cost past $100,000. Several say they'd love one but simply can't justify or afford the full setup.

Reliability and modernity complaints temper the enthusiasm. Not everyone is sold: one long-time shooter says there's always something wrong with it, criticizes the single-point focus system, and calls it overpriced and unreliable. Another calls the focusing slow, unreliable, and lacking weather sealing, saying the Fuji GFX line is taking its market. A separate comment laments the outdated lenses, wishing for new ultra high-end glass to match the sensor.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?