Nintendo DSi XLFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 49 mentions across 12 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment72%
PROS 72%
CONS 28%

Rank based on 49 mentions across 12 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want the sharpest, most accurate way to play original DS games without 3DS blur
  • You value a durable, long-lasting handheld that many owners still use after a decade or more
  • You're into homebrew/modding and want TWiLight Menu++ or classic emulation on a dedicated device

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You're not willing to pay rising secondhand prices, now often over $100
  • You need guaranteed new/mint condition, since genuinely new units barely exist anymore
  • You want GBA game compatibility built in without relying on homebrew workarounds

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choiceBest value
1Budget
Affordable priceExtremely durable buildComfortable ergonomicsNo 3D functionalityNon-foldable slab designSingle speaker only
Affordable price
Extremely durable build
Comfortable ergonomics
No 3D functionality
Non-foldable slab design
Single speaker only
2Mid
StreetPass and social featuresCustomization and personalityHuge legacy game libraryScarcity and rising pricesBattery aging and data riskConfusing naming and missing features
StreetPass and social features
Customization and personality
Huge legacy game library
Scarcity and rising prices
Battery aging and data risk
Confusing naming and missing features
3Mid
Huge, beloved game libraryConsole-quality graphicsStrong homebrew and emulation scenePSP Go ergonomics and dock scarcityDead pixel issuesLater slim models had inferior build/finish
Huge, beloved game library
Console-quality graphics
Strong homebrew and emulation scene
PSP Go ergonomics and dock scarcity
Dead pixel issues
Later slim models had inferior build/finish
4Budget
Strong nostalgia and emotional attachmentClever hardware engineeringColorization of original Game Boy gamesMuted, dim screenInconsistent early third-party graphicsShort console lifespan
Strong nostalgia and emotional attachment
Clever hardware engineering
Colorization of original Game Boy games
Muted, dim screen
Inconsistent early third-party graphics
Short console lifespan
5Mid
Deep nostalgia factorStrong game library tie-inDesirable special editionsFragile under rough useHard to find and pricey nowAccessory and game scarcity for rare shells
Deep nostalgia factor
Strong game library tie-in
Desirable special editions
Fragile under rough use
Hard to find and pricey now
Accessory and game scarcity for rare shells
6
Exceptional game libraryStrong nostalgic valueImpressive pseudo-3D and graphics capabilityPoor screen visibilityDifficult sound chipPerceived shortage of good games at launch
Exceptional game library
Strong nostalgic value
Impressive pseudo-3D and graphics capability
Poor screen visibility
Difficult sound chip
Perceived shortage of good games at launch
7Budget
Flipnote Studio creative legacyEasy to mod/hackBeloved DSiWare libraryNo GBA slotGBA emulation still buggyDSiWare transfer data loss
Flipnote Studio creative legacy
Easy to mod/hack
Beloved DSiWare library
No GBA slot
GBA emulation still buggy
DSiWare transfer data loss
8Budget
Sharper, clearer screen
Sharper, clearer screen
9Mid
Vibrant OLED screen
Vibrant OLED screen
10Mid
SteamOS Experience
SteamOS Experience
You are here
23Mid
Nintendo DSi XL
Nostalgic value and lasting memoriesSuperior IPS screensGreat for modding and homebrewRising secondhand pricesScreen dimness and yellowing on used unitsUsed units sold as new
Nintendo DSi XL
Nostalgic value and lasting memories
Superior IPS screens
Great for modding and homebrew
Rising secondhand prices
Screen dimness and yellowing on used units
Used units sold as new

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

The screen quality is the standout feature commenters return to again and again. Multiple owners highlight that DSi XL models use IPS screens, which they call vastly superior to the screen lottery of the 3DS line. The bigger, sharper, unscaled display makes original DS games look crisper than on 3DS/New 3DS XL hardware, where images get blurry from resizing. Some even prefer the DSi's screen over the regular 3DS despite lacking 3D capability, calling it the definitive way to experience DS titles.

Durability and longevity are frequently praised by long-term owners. Several commenters report using the same DSi XL for well over a decade, sometimes with the original battery still functioning. One owner's friend kept a unit 13 years; another still uses theirs daily 15 years after release. Units have survived drops, throws, and rough handling from childhood use. However, some report charging port issues and screen pixel bleeding after years of wear, showing durability isn't universal.

Rising prices and used-as-new scams are a growing pain point for buyers. Commenters describe prices climbing steadily, with some paying over $100 after shipping compared to around $40 just a few years earlier. One buyer was sold a used unit labeled as new and encouraged to seek a refund. Others note genuinely new-in-box units barely exist anymore, and finding clean-screened secondhand or refurbished units has become increasingly difficult as demand and YouTube attention drive prices up.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?