MSI Creator Z17From real comments

Verdict distilled from 43 mentions across 12 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment22%
PROS 22%
CONS 78%

Rank based on 43 mentions across 12 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want a thin, light 17in creator laptop with pen/touch support and strong port selection
  • You mainly work plugged in and can tune fan curves for better thermals
  • You value design and portability over maximum sustained gaming/rendering performance

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You need reliable, low-effort RAM/SSD upgrades without risking fragile screen connectors
  • You require built-in Ethernet without dongles
  • You plan sustained heavy rendering or gaming loads and are sensitive to fan noise or heat on the chassis

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Mid
MSI Creator 15
Color-accurate 4K OLED display
MSI Creator 15
Color-accurate 4K OLED display
2Premium
Dell Precision 5480
Clear mics and good speakersBright, high-quality displayGood resale and sale value over timeHigh price for the specsBattery life shorter than MacBook ProFan noise concerns
Dell Precision 5480
Clear mics and good speakers
Bright, high-quality display
Good resale and sale value over time
High price for the specs
Battery life shorter than MacBook Pro
Fan noise concerns
Best value
3Premium
Dell Precision 7720
Strong CAD/3D/gaming performanceRepairable and DIY-friendlyUpgradeable RAM and storageCharging and power issuesRAM upgrade requires keyboard removalBIOS downgrade limitation
Dell Precision 7720
Strong CAD/3D/gaming performance
Repairable and DIY-friendly
Upgradeable RAM and storage
Charging and power issues
RAM upgrade requires keyboard removal
BIOS downgrade limitation
4Premium
HP ZBook 17 G3
Upgradeable and serviceableDreamColor displayPowerful workstation configuration optionsMaintenance gaps during servicingBattery drains when idleKeyboard flex
HP ZBook 17 G3
Upgradeable and serviceable
DreamColor display
Powerful workstation configuration options
Maintenance gaps during servicing
Battery drains when idle
Keyboard flex
5Premium
Dell Precision 5760
Strong performance for engineering and creative workBusiness-grade designConfigurable and upgradeableOverheating concernsBulky sizeHigher price than comparable Mac specs
Dell Precision 5760
Strong performance for engineering and creative work
Business-grade design
Configurable and upgradeable
Overheating concerns
Bulky size
Higher price than comparable Mac specs
6Premium
Lenovo ThinkPad P70
Workstation-grade performanceExpandable storage and memoryBuilt-in color calibration sensorHigh price point4K display scaling issuesDifficult disassembly
Lenovo ThinkPad P70
Workstation-grade performance
Expandable storage and memory
Built-in color calibration sensor
High price point
4K display scaling issues
Difficult disassembly
7Premium
HP ZBook Studio G8
Clear, Loud AudioComprehensive Port SelectionSolid Professional PerformanceHigh PriceThermal Throttling Under LoadUpgradability Concerns
HP ZBook Studio G8
Clear, Loud Audio
Comprehensive Port Selection
Solid Professional Performance
High Price
Thermal Throttling Under Load
Upgradability Concerns
8Premium
Lenovo ThinkPad P15
Highly UpgradableRugged Build QualityWorkstation-Grade PerformanceFan Noise and Thermal ThrottlingWeak Battery LifeBuild/Quality Control Defects
Lenovo ThinkPad P15
Highly Upgradable
Rugged Build Quality
Workstation-Grade Performance
Fan Noise and Thermal Throttling
Weak Battery Life
Build/Quality Control Defects
9Premium
Lenovo ThinkPad P16
Strong workstation-grade performanceExcellent upgradeabilityHigh-quality display optionsInadequate 180W power adapterMissing Ethernet port on earlier modelsThermal throttling and cooling issues
Lenovo ThinkPad P16
Strong workstation-grade performance
Excellent upgradeability
High-quality display options
Inadequate 180W power adapter
Missing Ethernet port on earlier models
Thermal throttling and cooling issues
10Premium
Lenovo ThinkPad P1
Precise TrackPoint ControlSolid Build QualityStrong Workstation PerformanceRemoved TrackPoint Physical ButtonsThermal Throttling and Fan NoiseHigh Price
Lenovo ThinkPad P1
Precise TrackPoint Control
Solid Build Quality
Strong Workstation Performance
Removed TrackPoint Physical Buttons
Thermal Throttling and Fan Noise
High Price
You are here
31Premium
MSI Creator Z17
Capable performance when plugged inStrong port selection and designThin and light for its classSevere heat and throttlingFragile, risky internal upgradesHigh price relative to performance
MSI Creator Z17
Capable performance when plugged in
Strong port selection and design
Thin and light for its class
Severe heat and throttling
Fragile, risky internal upgrades
High price relative to performance

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Thermals and throttling are the laptop's biggest recurring complaint. Multiple owners describe the Z17 running hot even during light browsing, with fans spinning constantly and the metal case becoming painfully hot to touch. Users report GPU/CPU power-throttling due to thin-chassis cooling limits, with some noting a high-end RTX 3080 Ti performing closer to a 3060 Ti under sustained load. A few found relief by switching to high-performance fan curves in MSI Center, but many feel the cooling design doesn't match the premium price and specs.

Internal upgrades are technically possible but risky and poorly documented. Owners upgrading RAM or SSDs describe an inverted motherboard, extensive tape over cables, and fragile screen connectors that can break or cause display line issues if mishandled. Some wished they'd known that adding only an SSD requires just removing the back cover, without disconnecting the more delicate cables. Several regretted attempting upgrades themselves and warned others to get help or expect a repair trip to MSI if connectors fail.

Design and portability are appreciated, but everyday usability details frustrate users. Reviewers like the port selection, thin-and-light build, touchscreen with pen support, and newer vapor-chamber cooling design, calling it a strong alternative to bulkier gaming laptops for creator work. However, the missing Ethernet port is a frequent complaint requiring a dongle, the keyboard has small keys with redundant Enter/slash keys, and the trackpad's off-center position reportedly hurt typing efficiency for at least one long-time MSI user.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?