Honeywell RTH9585WFFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 35 mentions across 11 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment36%
PROS 36%
CONS 64%

Rank based on 35 mentions across 11 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want app-based WiFi control and remote scheduling
  • You already have a C-wire or are willing to add a C-wire adapter
  • You're comfortable following a detailed wiring video for a DIY install

What users love

Skip this if...

  • Your old system lacks a C-wire and you want a hassle-free swap
  • You need reliable dehumidifier or complex multi-stage/dual-fuel wiring support
  • You're not willing to troubleshoot occasional WiFi, time-sync, or screen freeze issues

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Mid
Helpful installation videosRoom sensor priority switchingHome automation integrationSensor pairing failuresNo Apple HomeKit supportHardware and display defects
Helpful installation videos
Room sensor priority switching
Home automation integration
Sensor pairing failures
No Apple HomeKit support
Hardware and display defects
2Mid
Fixable Connector IssuesCommunity Setup Guidance HelpfulAdjustable Temperature GraphsFrequent WiFi Connection Lost ErrorsLoose Internal HardwareConfusing Initial Setup
Fixable Connector Issues
Community Setup Guidance Helpful
Adjustable Temperature Graphs
Frequent WiFi Connection Lost Errors
Loose Internal Hardware
Confusing Initial Setup
3Budget
Strong Home Assistant / Zigbee integrationAffordable price and valueQuiet operation for some usersOnly on/off valve control, no position modulationNoise complaints from many unitsNo external sensor pairing or temperature offset
Strong Home Assistant / Zigbee integration
Affordable price and value
Quiet operation for some users
Only on/off valve control, no position modulation
Noise complaints from many units
No external sensor pairing or temperature offset
You are here
4Mid
Honeywell RTH9585WF
Easy DIY installation with video guidanceGood value at discount pricingConvenient WiFi and app controlConfusing wiring for non-standard setupsC-wire dependency causes installation headachesFan won't shut off properly
Honeywell RTH9585WF
Easy DIY installation with video guidance
Good value at discount pricing
Convenient WiFi and app control
Confusing wiring for non-standard setups
C-wire dependency causes installation headaches
Fan won't shut off properly
5Mid
Straightforward Wi-Fi thermostat installationApp-based remote temperature controlAutomatic heat/cool changeover availableDifficulty setting up Wi-Fi and finding CRC codeInconsistent HVAC controlWi-Fi connectivity and 'offline' issues
Straightforward Wi-Fi thermostat installation
App-based remote temperature control
Automatic heat/cool changeover available
Difficulty setting up Wi-Fi and finding CRC code
Inconsistent HVAC control
Wi-Fi connectivity and 'offline' issues
6
Factory reset recovers stuck unitsHelps catch tampering or misconfigurationSimple once configured correctlyLockout and other settings hard to locateConfusing system-type configurationWi-Fi and screen reliability issues
Factory reset recovers stuck units
Helps catch tampering or misconfiguration
Simple once configured correctly
Lockout and other settings hard to locate
Confusing system-type configuration
Wi-Fi and screen reliability issues
7Mid
Effective once properly configuredAdjustable via ISU advanced settings7-day programmable schedulingConfusing setup and poor manualCycling and fan running issuesTemperature control and sensor problems
Effective once properly configured
Adjustable via ISU advanced settings
7-day programmable scheduling
Confusing setup and poor manual
Cycling and fan running issues
Temperature control and sensor problems
8Premium
Easy InstallationGood Value with DiscountsAttractive, Well-Built DesignWiring and Compatibility ConfusionUnreliable Software and SchedulingDiscontinued Support for Older Generations
Easy Installation
Good Value with Discounts
Attractive, Well-Built Design
Wiring and Compatibility Confusion
Unreliable Software and Scheduling
Discontinued Support for Older Generations
9Budget
Affordable priceEasy Home Assistant/Zigbee integrationAdaptive mode improves quiet operation and efficiencyOn/off-only valve controlMotor noise during operationConnectivity and pairing issues
Affordable price
Easy Home Assistant/Zigbee integration
Adaptive mode improves quiet operation and efficiency
On/off-only valve control
Motor noise during operation
Connectivity and pairing issues
10Mid
Helpful once understoodFlexible scheduling conceptReset resolves some display/mode glitchesConfusing wiring for heat pump/aux systemsConfusing programming/schedule logicShort-cycling behavior
Helpful once understood
Flexible scheduling concept
Reset resolves some display/mode glitches
Confusing wiring for heat pump/aux systems
Confusing programming/schedule logic
Short-cycling behavior

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Installation is doable for most, but wiring complexity varies wildly by system. Several users completed the swap quickly and painlessly, including a 67-year-old first-timer and another user done within an hour. However, others faced confusing wire counts (5 to 8 wires), unfamiliar colors like orange, brown, or blue, and uncertainty about RH/RC jumpers, leaving many needing extra research or help to finish safely.

The C-wire requirement is the most common pain point. Multiple commenters discovered their old systems lacked a C-wire, requiring fishing new wire, buying a Honeywell C-wire adapter, or hunting for a hidden/unused wire in the wall or furnace. One user noted the adapter doesn't work with heat-only systems, complicating things further for some installs.

Post-install software quirks affect a meaningful minority. After working initially, some units developed a frozen unresponsive touchscreen, a fan that wouldn't shut off even after factory reset, WiFi that dropped and wouldn't reconnect, incorrect time or daylight-savings handling, and disappearing advanced-settings menus over time, requiring troubleshooting or workarounds users found frustrating.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?