HIFIMAN Edition SFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 52 mentions across 11 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment56%
PROS 56%
CONS 44%

Rank based on 52 mentions across 11 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want detailed, spacious planar sound at a strong price-to-performance ratio
  • You have a larger head and can get a proper seal with the headband
  • You want headphones that scale well with better amps/DACs and take EQ well

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You have a smaller head or wear glasses, since fit can be loose and cause squeaking
  • You need rock-solid build quality, since some report plastic hinges cracking
  • You're sensitive to headband hotspots or dislike single-piece (non-suspension) headbands

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Premium
Apple AirPods Pro 2
Transparency ModeNoise CancellationSound QualityiOS/Apple Ecosystem Lock-inDurability/Crackling ConcernsHigh Price
Apple AirPods Pro 2
Transparency Mode
Noise Cancellation
Sound Quality
iOS/Apple Ecosystem Lock-in
Durability/Crackling Concerns
High Price
2Mid
Skullcandy Crusher
Signature haptic bass slider
Skullcandy Crusher
Signature haptic bass slider
3Premium
Sennheiser HD 490 Pro
Exceptional comfortStrong for gaming and imagingImprovement over HD 650/6XXIrritating L/R lettering inside padsBuild/pad quality issues reportedHigh price relative to alternatives
Sennheiser HD 490 Pro
Exceptional comfort
Strong for gaming and imaging
Improvement over HD 650/6XX
Irritating L/R lettering inside pads
Build/pad quality issues reported
High price relative to alternatives
4Mid
Sennheiser HD 25
Exceptional durabilityBalanced, quality soundFully repairable/modularCable-to-driver cutout issuesStrong clamping forceUnconventional cable entry side
Sennheiser HD 25
Exceptional durability
Balanced, quality sound
Fully repairable/modular
Cable-to-driver cutout issues
Strong clamping force
Unconventional cable entry side
5Mid
Philips SHP9500S
Exceptional comfort
Philips SHP9500S
Exceptional comfort
Best value
6Premium
Denon AH-D9200
Smooth, detailed treble and clarityStrong perceived value and end-game satisfactionTight, deep bassHigh price pointSibilant or fatiguing treble for sensitive earsTight fit for larger ears
Denon AH-D9200
Smooth, detailed treble and clarity
Strong perceived value and end-game satisfaction
Tight, deep bass
High price point
Sibilant or fatiguing treble for sensitive ears
Tight fit for larger ears
7Premium
Bose Noise Cancelling Headphones 700
Excellent Call and Mic QualityAll-Day ComfortIndustry-Leading Noise CancellationHigh Price PointInconsistent Call Clarity in Certain EnvironmentsBluetooth Pairing Problems
Bose Noise Cancelling Headphones 700
Excellent Call and Mic Quality
All-Day Comfort
Industry-Leading Noise Cancellation
High Price Point
Inconsistent Call Clarity in Certain Environments
Bluetooth Pairing Problems
8Premium
Shure SRH1540
Neutral, accurate soundExceptional comfortGreat detail and resolutionPerceived as 'boring' by some listenersElevated mid-bass/sub-bass not fully neutralSound highly dependent on seal and source
Shure SRH1540
Neutral, accurate sound
Exceptional comfort
Great detail and resolution
Perceived as 'boring' by some listeners
Elevated mid-bass/sub-bass not fully neutral
Sound highly dependent on seal and source
9Budget
Philips SHP9500
Exceptional value for moneyOutstanding comfortDetailed, neutral sound signatureLight or rolled-off bassCheap-feeling build qualityPerceived treble grain/sibilance
Philips SHP9500
Exceptional value for money
Outstanding comfort
Detailed, neutral sound signature
Light or rolled-off bass
Cheap-feeling build quality
Perceived treble grain/sibilance
10Budget
Apple EarPods
Excellent Sound Quality for PriceComfortable for Extended UseNo Charging RequiredLimited Noise IsolationBuild Quality ConcernsNot Secure for Active Use
Apple EarPods
Excellent Sound Quality for Price
Comfortable for Extended Use
No Charging Required
Limited Noise Isolation
Build Quality Concerns
Not Secure for Active Use
You are here
31Mid
HIFIMAN Edition S
Detailed, immersive soundExcellent value for moneyWide soundstage and imagingHeadband comfort and hotspotsLoose fit for smaller headsUnderwhelming or inconsistent sound for some
HIFIMAN Edition S
Detailed, immersive sound
Excellent value for money
Wide soundstage and imaging
Headband comfort and hotspots
Loose fit for smaller heads
Underwhelming or inconsistent sound for some

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Many listeners call the Edition S/XS an outstanding value that punches above its price. Multiple commenters say it's the best sound-for-money headphone they've owned, especially at sale prices around $200. One called $700 worth of performance from the pair with a DAC 'incredible,' while others cited deals near $209-$219 as amazing. Several highlight that it takes EQ well and scales with more powerful amps, making it flexible across budgets and setups, from phones to dedicated DACs.

Sound quality impressions lean strongly positive, praising detail, soundstage, and immersion. Reviewers describe hearing new details in familiar tracks, a big immersive soundstage, and precise imaging, with some saying it's 'basically perfect' for music and gaming alike. Comparisons to the Sundara and Ananda suggest better bass and detail than Sundara, while some found it comparably neutral to well-regarded reference headphones according to third-party measurement sites, though a minority felt the sound was underwhelming or thin versus expectations.

Fit and build quality are the most consistent complaints across listeners. Several people with smaller or average heads report the headband is too loose, causing the earcups to shift, fail to seal, or squeak against glasses. Others describe hotspots or discomfort from the stiff, non-suspension headband, and at least two mention plastic headband hinges cracking after just weeks of use. Some worked around fit issues by bending the headband, while others returned the headphones entirely.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?