Garmin Forerunner 45SFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 7 mentions across 5 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment71%
PROS 71%
CONS 29%

Rank based on 7 mentions across 5 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want a screen that stays readable in bright outdoor sunlight
  • You want a GPS watch with several days of battery life between charges
  • You like customizing watch faces and swapping bands

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You need highly accurate optical heart rate readings during intense workouts
  • You plan to use GPS tracking constantly and need long battery life throughout
  • You're unsure whether the 39mm case size fits your wrist preference

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Premium
Exceptional battery lifeRugged, durable build with sapphire glassImproved maps and touchscreen navigationHigh price makes upgrading hard to justifyInconsistent screen visibility on some solar unitsHeart rate sensor bugs
Exceptional battery life
Rugged, durable build with sapphire glass
Improved maps and touchscreen navigation
High price makes upgrading hard to justify
Inconsistent screen visibility on some solar units
Heart rate sensor bugs
2Mid
Always-on displayMeaningful upgrade from older Apple WatchesSolid battery life for an always-on watchNot worth upgrading from Series 4Feels fragile without a caseNeeds nightly charging with always-on enabled
Always-on display
Meaningful upgrade from older Apple Watches
Solid battery life for an always-on watch
Not worth upgrading from Series 4
Feels fragile without a case
Needs nightly charging with always-on enabled
3Mid
Impressive Battery LifeVersatile Fitness Tracking FeaturesGorgeous AMOLED DisplayPrice ConcernsScreen Smudging and ScratchesIssues with Body Composition Measurement
Impressive Battery Life
Versatile Fitness Tracking Features
Gorgeous AMOLED Display
Price Concerns
Screen Smudging and Scratches
Issues with Body Composition Measurement
Best value
4Mid
Excellent Value for PriceGood Heart Rate TrackingLong Battery LifeInconsistent Heart Rate TrackingLimited Storage CapacitySoftware Bugs and Glitches
Excellent Value for Price
Good Heart Rate Tracking
Long Battery Life
Inconsistent Heart Rate Tracking
Limited Storage Capacity
Software Bugs and Glitches
5Budget
Impressive Battery LifeGreat Price-to-Quality RatioLightweight and Comfortable DesignLimited Storage CapacityInaccurate Sleep TrackingFragile Screen
Impressive Battery Life
Great Price-to-Quality Ratio
Lightweight and Comfortable Design
Limited Storage Capacity
Inaccurate Sleep Tracking
Fragile Screen
6Premium
Excellent battery life for ultras
Excellent battery life for ultras
7Budget
Long Battery LifeAccurate Heart Rate MonitoringBuilt-in Alexa FunctionalityBattery Life DiscrepanciesInaccurate Tracking for Some ActivitiesStrap Durability Issues
Long Battery Life
Accurate Heart Rate Monitoring
Built-in Alexa Functionality
Battery Life Discrepancies
Inaccurate Tracking for Some Activities
Strap Durability Issues
8Premium
Excellent battery lifeGreat fit for smaller wristsStrong outdoor sunlight visibilityDim or hard-to-read sapphire displayBulky or heavy feelHigh price for display quality received
Excellent battery life
Great fit for smaller wrists
Strong outdoor sunlight visibility
Dim or hard-to-read sapphire display
Bulky or heavy feel
High price for display quality received
9Mid
Long-term durabilityGreat value for featuresRugged build qualityHeart rate sensor accuracyIndoor display visibility only averageReliability concerns in comparison to newer models
Long-term durability
Great value for features
Rugged build quality
Heart rate sensor accuracy
Indoor display visibility only average
Reliability concerns in comparison to newer models
10Premium
Long battery lifeScratch-proof sapphire glassDetailed sports and training dataHigh priceInconsistent sleep and body battery trackingSapphire screen brightness/visibility concerns
Long battery life
Scratch-proof sapphire glass
Detailed sports and training data
High price
Inconsistent sleep and body battery tracking
Sapphire screen brightness/visibility concerns
You are here
31Mid
Garmin Forerunner 45S
Customizable bands and watch facesLong battery lifeSunlight-readable transflective displayBattery drains faster with GPS enabledQuestionable heart rate accuracy
Garmin Forerunner 45S
Customizable bands and watch faces
Long battery life
Sunlight-readable transflective display
Battery drains faster with GPS enabled
Questionable heart rate accuracy

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

The transflective display sets the 45S apart from typical smartwatch screens outdoors. One commenter specifically pointed out that the transflective screen doesn't require backlight to be seen and actually becomes easier to read the brighter the sun gets, unlike LED, LCD, or OLED smartwatch displays which they described as struggling outdoors. They compared it favorably to Casio digital watches for this reason, and noted it also helps extend battery life significantly compared to smartwatches like the Apple Watch.

Battery life is strong without GPS but drops noticeably when GPS is active. A reviewer clarified that without constant GPS use, the watch can last 5-7 days based on their experience, though enabling GPS tracking reduces this considerably. This distinction is useful for buyers weighing everyday smartwatch use against dedicated GPS run tracking, since expectations should differ depending on usage mode and how often GPS features are engaged during workouts.

Customization options like swappable bands and watch faces pleased some users. One commenter clarified that despite initial confusion, the band can in fact be removed and replaced, pointing to an instructional video for guidance. Another user echoed this enthusiastically, stating they love being able to get different watch faces and change the watch band, pushing back against a less favorable review and calling the customization options a highlight of ownership.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?