Fitbit Charge HRFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 42 mentions across 13 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment26%
PROS 26%
CONS 74%

Rank based on 42 mentions across 13 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want a simple motivator for step and activity tracking with silent call/alarm vibration
  • You like convenient features like wake-on-wrist-turn and tap-to-cycle display screens
  • You don't need swim or heavy-rain waterproofing and mainly track daily activity and sleep

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You need accurate heart rate data for serious cardio training
  • You want a device that survives past the warranty period without band or screen failures
  • You need reliable Bluetooth syncing and hassle-free charging/setup

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choiceBest value
1Budget
Great value for priceExcellent battery lifeSolid fitness and sleep tracking for casual usePersistent syncing issuesInconsistent sensor accuracyBattery drain complaints early on
Great value for price
Excellent battery life
Solid fitness and sleep tracking for casual use
Persistent syncing issues
Inconsistent sensor accuracy
Battery drain complaints early on
2Mid
Stylish, appealing designStrong value for moneyLong-term durabilityBattery and charging failuresDisappointing screen qualityPoor customer service experience
Stylish, appealing design
Strong value for money
Long-term durability
Battery and charging failures
Disappointing screen quality
Poor customer service experience
3Mid
Easy hidden charging portAccurate HRM for weight trainingPositive overall satisfaction and upgrade experienceBluetooth pairing problemsNo GPS for distance/paceSync/charging assembly confusion
Easy hidden charging port
Accurate HRM for weight training
Positive overall satisfaction and upgrade experience
Bluetooth pairing problems
No GPS for distance/pace
Sync/charging assembly confusion
4Premium
Bright AMOLED displaySlim, lightweight designStrong battery lifeAMOLED sunlight and battery tradeoffs disliked by someUnreliable sleep trackingScreen scratch susceptibility and build concerns
Bright AMOLED display
Slim, lightweight design
Strong battery life
AMOLED sunlight and battery tradeoffs disliked by some
Unreliable sleep tracking
Screen scratch susceptibility and build concerns
5Mid
Built-in GPSLong battery lifeGood value for moneyMissing basic appsInaccurate sleep trackingMissing imperial units
Built-in GPS
Long battery life
Good value for money
Missing basic apps
Inaccurate sleep tracking
Missing imperial units
6Mid
Accurate trackingWorks well for arm-restricted activitiesEasy food logging and appWristband confusion causes inaccurate readingsEasy to loseDiscontinued product
Accurate tracking
Works well for arm-restricted activities
Easy food logging and app
Wristband confusion causes inaccurate readings
Easy to lose
Discontinued product
7Budget
No subscription requiredFrees the wrist for traditional watchesStrong heart rate accuracyInaccurate step and distance tracking on bicepInconsistent sleep tracking accuracyUnreliable scoring metrics
No subscription required
Frees the wrist for traditional watches
Strong heart rate accuracy
Inaccurate step and distance tracking on bicep
Inconsistent sleep tracking accuracy
Unreliable scoring metrics
8Mid
External HR Strap Pairing24/7 Heart Rate TrackingEasy USB ChargingBattery Life ConcernsHR Sensor Lag During WorkoutsInconsistent 24/7 HR Sampling
External HR Strap Pairing
24/7 Heart Rate Tracking
Easy USB Charging
Battery Life Concerns
HR Sensor Lag During Workouts
Inconsistent 24/7 HR Sampling
9Mid
Bright, high-quality AMOLED screenLight, comfortable, slim designPolar Flow app and no-subscription ecosystemDivisive strap designUI lag (pre-update)High price relative to features
Bright, high-quality AMOLED screen
Light, comfortable, slim design
Polar Flow app and no-subscription ecosystem
Divisive strap design
UI lag (pre-update)
High price relative to features
10Budget
Durable against water and washingEasy syncingMotivates activityStep counter fails to resetConfusing waterproof/swim claimsDifficult battery compartment
Durable against water and washing
Easy syncing
Motivates activity
Step counter fails to reset
Confusing waterproof/swim claims
Difficult battery compartment
You are here
31Mid
Fitbit Charge HR
Fixable with reset/troubleshooting stepsMotivates activity and weight lossSilent call and alarm vibrationCharging and power failuresBluetooth pairing and sync issuesHeart rate accuracy questioned
Fitbit Charge HR
Fixable with reset/troubleshooting steps
Motivates activity and weight loss
Silent call and alarm vibration
Charging and power failures
Bluetooth pairing and sync issues
Heart rate accuracy questioned

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Motivating for everyday activity tracking, at least at first. Multiple users report feeling motivated to improve fitness, with one losing 7 pounds within a week and finding it comfortable after an initial adjustment period. Convenient features like automatic wrist-rotation wake and double-tap screen cycling through stats add to the everyday usability, along with silent call and alarm vibration that lets users keep their phone ringer off while staying aware of notifications.

Durability and hardware reliability are recurring complaints. Several commenters describe the band separating from the screen after only three to four months, sometimes on multiple replacement units, and one user reported three separate units failing within a year despite gentle use. Others report screens going permanently black, batteries refusing to charge out of the box, or displays stuck on a 'V128' code, with customer support sometimes declining replacements once the one-year warranty lapsed.

Tracking accuracy and connectivity frustrate many users. Heart rate readings are repeatedly called inaccurate compared to chest strap monitors, with one user calling the built-in sensor's claims false advertising, while others note failed HR pickup during cardio. Calorie and step counts are described as inconsistent, including steps counted from arm movement while not worn. Bluetooth pairing and syncing failures, stalled setup screens, and unresponsive resets are also commonly reported issues.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?