Cambridge Audio DacMagic PlusFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 36 mentions across 12 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment30%
PROS 30%
CONS 70%

Rank based on 36 mentions across 12 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want a flat, uncoloured DAC that noticeably improves system sound for a reasonable price
  • You mainly need a DAC/preamp paired with speakers rather than high-end headphones
  • You're comfortable doing DIY repairs if capacitors or regulators eventually fail

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You want a powerful, refined headphone amp for demanding cans like HD800 or T1
  • You expect long-term reliability without eventual capacitor/PSU or LED repairs
  • You dislike ambiguous controls and a missing manual for preamp/filter modes

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choiceBest value
1Upper
SMSL SU-9~$450 · 1.3× cheaper
Strong value for the pricePunchy, detailed sound with good bassBluetooth and MQA convenienceConsidered pricey by someMidrange can sound thin or harshSound-color feature seen as ineffective by some
SMSL SU-9~$450 · 1.3× cheaper
Strong value for the price
Punchy, detailed sound with good bass
Bluetooth and MQA convenience
Considered pricey by some
Midrange can sound thin or harsh
Sound-color feature seen as ineffective by some
2Mid
JDS Labs Element~$349 · 1.7× cheaper
Outstanding customer supportDrives demanding headphones wellCompact all-in-one designHigh price relative to competitorsNo balanced output by defaultAwkward controls and web-based EQ concerns
JDS Labs Element~$349 · 1.7× cheaper
Outstanding customer support
Drives demanding headphones well
Compact all-in-one design
High price relative to competitors
No balanced output by default
Awkward controls and web-based EQ concerns
3Upper
iFi Micro iDSD BL~$599 · similar price
Strong value versus pricier alternatives3D and Xbass tone controlsDrives hard-to-power headphonesNot truly pocketablePricey versus desktop alternativesAmp noise reported
iFi Micro iDSD BL~$599 · similar price
Strong value versus pricier alternatives
3D and Xbass tone controls
Drives hard-to-power headphones
Not truly pocketable
Pricey versus desktop alternatives
Amp noise reported
4Upper
SMSL VMV SAP1~$600 · similar price
Excellent value for moneyDrives demanding headphones with easeExceeds initial expectationsInconsistent regional pricingCheap-feeling volume knobLimited availability at some retailers
SMSL VMV SAP1~$600 · similar price
Excellent value for money
Drives demanding headphones with ease
Exceeds initial expectations
Inconsistent regional pricing
Cheap-feeling volume knob
Limited availability at some retailers
5Premium
RME ADI-2 DAC~$1,099 · 1.8× pricier
Powerful Parametric EQNeutral, Transparent SoundExtensive Feature Set / ValueFlat or Narrow SoundstageDry/Clinical Character Out of the BoxStock Power Supply Limitations
RME ADI-2 DAC~$1,099 · 1.8× pricier
Powerful Parametric EQ
Neutral, Transparent Sound
Extensive Feature Set / Value
Flat or Narrow Soundstage
Dry/Clinical Character Out of the Box
Stock Power Supply Limitations
6Upper
SMSL D400EX~$650 · similar price
High owner satisfactionSmooth, non-fatiguing AKM soundAdjustable filters and sound-color settingsSlightly lean bass versus rivalsLacks emotional immersion for some listenersLimited official availability in some regions
SMSL D400EX~$650 · similar price
High owner satisfaction
Smooth, non-fatiguing AKM sound
Adjustable filters and sound-color settings
Slightly lean bass versus rivals
Lacks emotional immersion for some listeners
Limited official availability in some regions
7Mid
iFi xDSD~$399 · 1.5× cheaper
Detailed, warm signature soundExcellent Bluetooth performanceFun XBass and XSpace tone shapingBattery wear concerns from desktop useHigh price relative to featuresFirmware regressions and quirks
iFi xDSD~$399 · 1.5× cheaper
Detailed, warm signature sound
Excellent Bluetooth performance
Fun XBass and XSpace tone shaping
Battery wear concerns from desktop use
High price relative to features
Firmware regressions and quirks
8Mid
SMSL H400~$320 · 1.9× cheaper
Strong power deliveryReliable alternative to competitorsSound-tuning flexibilityCosts more than cheaper alternativesHigh price
SMSL H400~$320 · 1.9× cheaper
Strong power delivery
Reliable alternative to competitors
Sound-tuning flexibility
Costs more than cheaper alternatives
High price
9Upper
iFi Go Bar Kensei~$449 · 1.3× cheaper
Exceptional sound detailK2HD harmonic restorationOutperforms rival donglesHigh priceWeak value vs cheaper alternativesUnclear upgrade over own lineup
iFi Go Bar Kensei~$449 · 1.3× cheaper
Exceptional sound detail
K2HD harmonic restoration
Outperforms rival dongles
High price
Weak value vs cheaper alternatives
Unclear upgrade over own lineup
You are here
10Upper
Cambridge Audio DacMagic Plus~$599
Repairable designFlexible DAC/preamp modesGreat value for moneyCapacitor and PSU reliability issuesPower and connectivity failuresHigh-pitched whining noise
Cambridge Audio DacMagic Plus~$599
Repairable design
Flexible DAC/preamp modes
Great value for money
Capacitor and PSU reliability issues
Power and connectivity failures
High-pitched whining noise

Who wins on what (similar price)

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

As a DAC, it delivers genuinely transparent, uncoloured sound that impresses many owners. Multiple commenters describe the DacMagic Plus as near-flat in frequency response, comparable to far pricier units like the Benchmark DAC, with no added colouration. One owner reported needing much less amplifier volume after adding it, crediting a clear improvement in sound quality across genres. It's frequently called great value for money and a 'helluva good unit' at its price point, especially when used purely as a DAC feeding a separate amp or preamp rather than relying on its internal headphone stage.

The built-in headphone amp is a consistent weak point for demanding headphones. Several users found the headphone output thin, overly bright, and lacking texture, with one saying it made expensive headphones like the Beyerdynamic T1 sound worse than much cheaper alternatives. Others note it was added as a secondary feature to an originally DAC-only design and isn't very powerful, recommending an external amp or used receiver instead for serious headphone listening. Some describe the overall CA house sound as 'sterile.'

Long-term reliability is a real concern, with whining noise and component failures common. Many comments describe a recurring high-pitched whine traced to failing electrolytic capacitors or voltage regulators, prompting extensive DIY repair threads and capacitor-replacement guides. Others report units that won't power on, lose USB/sample-rate detection, produce distorted or muffled sound, or suffer firmware issues and failed blue LEDs after years of use. Several commenters attribute this to cheap PSU/decoupling caps and poor heat management on the linear regulators, suggesting design-level cost-cutting after Cambridge Audio's acquisition.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?