Blackmagic URSA Cine 17KFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 44 mentions across 12 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment63%
PROS 63%
CONS 37%

Rank based on 44 mentions across 12 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want a 65mm/large-format look without renting an Alexa 65 or IMAX camera
  • You shoot VFX plates, immersive LED walls, or projection content needing extreme resolution headroom
  • You already own or can source medium-format glass that covers the 65mm sensor

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You need internal ND filters or a lightweight solo/handheld run-and-gun setup
  • You can't manage massive BRAW file sizes and slow media transfer workflows
  • You need guaranteed reliability for high-stakes professional shoots

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Premium
RED Epic-X~$28,000 · similar price
Filmic image qualityStrong high-ISO performanceDragon sensor regarded as RED's bestHeavy lighting requirements for low lightHeavy post-production demandsLong-term reliability concerns
RED Epic-X~$28,000 · similar price
Filmic image quality
Strong high-ISO performance
Dragon sensor regarded as RED's best
Heavy lighting requirements for low light
Heavy post-production demands
Long-term reliability concerns
Best value
2Premium
RED Epic Dragon~$29,000 · similar price
Exceptional image quality and dynamic rangeBeloved by long-term and repeat ownersStrong value on the used marketDemanding low-light lighting requirementsFan and audio noise concernsMisleading '16-bit' marketing claims
RED Epic Dragon~$29,000 · similar price
Exceptional image quality and dynamic range
Beloved by long-term and repeat owners
Strong value on the used market
Demanding low-light lighting requirements
Fan and audio noise concerns
Misleading '16-bit' marketing claims
3Premium
Sony Venice 2~$58,000 · 1.9× pricier
Balanced, film-like color scienceAttainable pricing for used Venice 1Best-in-class internal ND systemHeavy body for solo operatorsMissing high-frame-rate optionsVery high price relative to alternatives
Sony Venice 2~$58,000 · 1.9× pricier
Balanced, film-like color science
Attainable pricing for used Venice 1
Best-in-class internal ND system
Heavy body for solo operators
Missing high-frame-rate options
Very high price relative to alternatives
4Premium
RED V-Raptor~$24,995 · 1.2× cheaper
Exceptional Image QualityExtended Highlight Dynamic RangeCompact, Lighter BodyExpensive AccessoriesExtended Highlight GhostingLost Modularity
RED V-Raptor~$24,995 · 1.2× cheaper
Exceptional Image Quality
Extended Highlight Dynamic Range
Compact, Lighter Body
Expensive Accessories
Extended Highlight Ghosting
Lost Modularity
5Premium
Sony Venice~$40,000 · 1.3× pricier
Excellent image qualityGreat value on used marketInternal ND systemHeavy for solo operationCostly accessories and proprietary mediaVideo-like or 'soap opera' look for some viewers
Sony Venice~$40,000 · 1.3× pricier
Excellent image quality
Great value on used market
Internal ND system
Heavy for solo operation
Costly accessories and proprietary media
Video-like or 'soap opera' look for some viewers
6Premium
RED V-Raptor X~$29,995 · similar price
Extended Highlight dynamic rangeCompelling price relative to competitorsGlobal shutter full-frame sensorExpensive proprietary accessoriesColor science complaintsEH mode motion and highlight tradeoffs
RED V-Raptor X~$29,995 · similar price
Extended Highlight dynamic range
Compelling price relative to competitors
Global shutter full-frame sensor
Expensive proprietary accessories
Color science complaints
EH mode motion and highlight tradeoffs
7Premium
RED Epic-W~$24,500 · 1.2× cheaper
Considered worth the investmentFuture-proof capabilityHigh resolution sensorHigh overall costDynamic range trails competitorsNaming and spec confusion
RED Epic-W~$24,500 · 1.2× cheaper
Considered worth the investment
Future-proof capability
High resolution sensor
High overall cost
Dynamic range trails competitors
Naming and spec confusion
8Premium
RED Weapon 6K~$29,500 · similar price
Outstanding Resale ValueExcellent Dragon Sensor Image QualityIntercuts Well With Other CamerasSteep Menu and Settings Learning CurveExtra Rigging and Accessory CostsHeavy Grain Emulation in Sample Footage
RED Weapon 6K~$29,500 · similar price
Outstanding Resale Value
Excellent Dragon Sensor Image Quality
Intercuts Well With Other Cameras
Steep Menu and Settings Learning Curve
Extra Rigging and Accessory Costs
Heavy Grain Emulation in Sample Footage
9Premium
Canon EOS C500 Mark II~$15,999 · 1.9× cheaper
Full-frame RAW image qualityListens to DP community feedbackOngoing firmware support and updatesLacks 4K 120fps slow motionFootage softness and firmware/media issuesHigh price
Canon EOS C500 Mark II~$15,999 · 1.9× cheaper
Full-frame RAW image quality
Listens to DP community feedback
Ongoing firmware support and updates
Lacks 4K 120fps slow motion
Footage softness and firmware/media issues
High price
10Premium
Canon EOS C700~$28,000 · similar price
Global shutter and high frame rate external recordingColor matching with C300 Mark IIEfficient compressed codec workflowVery high price versus competitorsFlat, DSLR-like color scienceCamera line reportedly discontinued quickly
Canon EOS C700~$28,000 · similar price
Global shutter and high frame rate external recording
Color matching with C300 Mark II
Efficient compressed codec workflow
Very high price versus competitors
Flat, DSLR-like color science
Camera line reportedly discontinued quickly
You are here
11Premium
Blackmagic URSA Cine 17K~$29,995
Affordable 65mm large-format accessImpressive image quality and dynamic rangeUseful for VFX and immersive/large-display contentLens compatibility and resolving power concernsMarketing overstates true IMAX equivalenceMassive file sizes and slow transfers
Blackmagic URSA Cine 17K~$29,995
Affordable 65mm large-format access
Impressive image quality and dynamic range
Useful for VFX and immersive/large-display content
Lens compatibility and resolving power concerns
Marketing overstates true IMAX equivalence
Massive file sizes and slow transfers

Who wins on what (similar price)

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

A 65mm sensor at a disruptive price point. Multiple commenters frame the 17K as democratizing 65mm cinematography, offering a format previously locked behind $90-100K Alexa 65 or IMAX rentals for roughly $20-25K. Users describe it as finally letting owner-operators, universities, and mid-sized studios access a large-format look, comparing it favorably to renting from expensive houses, though some note the 65mm designation is more about sensor size than raw IMAX-equivalence.

Striking image quality with strong dynamic range. Commenters who shot with the camera describe being 'blown away' by detail resolution, soft highlight rolloff, and a clean 16-stop, 12-bit color image, with comparisons made favorably against RED's 8K Monstro footage. The RGBW sensor's clever readout technique is highlighted as technically impressive versus competitors' Bayer designs, though a few felt demo footage looked flatter than expected for a large-format camera.

Practical friction points around files, lenses, and reliability. Several users flagged huge BRAW file sizes and slow transfer speeds as workflow burdens, plus the absence of internal ND filters on the 17K unlike the 12K variant. Sourcing lenses that can actually cover or resolve the 65mm sensor is repeatedly cited as a limiting cost factor. A handful of commenters also reported past Blackmagic camera failures or bricking on professional shoots, raising reliability concerns.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?