Asus ROG Strix Scar 15From real comments

Verdict distilled from 47 mentions across 13 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment45%
PROS 45%
CONS 55%

Rank based on 47 mentions across 13 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want strong CPU/GPU gaming performance with a high-refresh QHD or FHD display
  • You value a distinctive, well-regarded keyboard feel for gaming
  • You're fine using desk/cooling pad setups and don't need a webcam or fingerprint scanner

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You're sensitive to fan noise or need a quiet laptop for shared spaces
  • You need reliable out-of-box software/drivers without troubleshooting Windows update or Wi-Fi bugs
  • You want built-in biometric security (fingerprint/face unlock) or a webcam

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Premium
Lenovo Legion 7
Premium build and design
Lenovo Legion 7
Premium build and design
2Mid
Asus ROG Strix G15
Upgradeable RAM and storage
Asus ROG Strix G15
Upgradeable RAM and storage
3Mid
MSI Crosshair 15
Distinctive yellow design
MSI Crosshair 15
Distinctive yellow design
4Premium
Alienware Area-51m
High Performance for Gaming and ProductivityExceptional Cooling PerformanceGood Build QualityHigh Price PointHeavy and Bulky DesignLimited Future Upgrade Options
Alienware Area-51m
High Performance for Gaming and Productivity
Exceptional Cooling Performance
Good Build Quality
High Price Point
Heavy and Bulky Design
Limited Future Upgrade Options
Best value
5Mid
Lenovo Legion 5 Pro
Strong gaming/creative performanceExcellent displayMinimalist, non-gamer design with toggleable RGB logoBulky, heavy power adapterTrackpad inconsistencies for some usersLaptop weight impacts portability
Lenovo Legion 5 Pro
Strong gaming/creative performance
Excellent display
Minimalist, non-gamer design with toggleable RGB logo
Bulky, heavy power adapter
Trackpad inconsistencies for some users
Laptop weight impacts portability
6Premium
Alienware Area-51
High-Quality Build and DesignImpressive Thermal ManagementGood Display Brightness and ColorHigh Price PointProprietary Components IssuesSubpar Included Peripherals
Alienware Area-51
High-Quality Build and Design
Impressive Thermal Management
Good Display Brightness and Color
High Price Point
Proprietary Components Issues
Subpar Included Peripherals
7Premium
Alienware Aurora 16X
Good Performance for GamingDecent Build QualityAffordable Pricing for SpecsPoor Screen Response TimeIssues with Customer SupportLimited Upgradeability
Alienware Aurora 16X
Good Performance for Gaming
Decent Build Quality
Affordable Pricing for Specs
Poor Screen Response Time
Issues with Customer Support
Limited Upgradeability
8Premium
Acer Predator Triton 14
Haptic Touchpad with Pen SupportBeautiful DesignGood Battery LifeUnderwhelming Speaker QualityHigh Price PointLimited VRAM for Gaming
Acer Predator Triton 14
Haptic Touchpad with Pen Support
Beautiful Design
Good Battery Life
Underwhelming Speaker Quality
High Price Point
Limited VRAM for Gaming
9Mid
Lenovo Legion Slim 5
Strong value for moneyQuality OLED/high-nit displaySolid build quality and keyboardWeak speakersMediocre battery lifeDisplay quality variance between units
Lenovo Legion Slim 5
Strong value for money
Quality OLED/high-nit display
Solid build quality and keyboard
Weak speakers
Mediocre battery life
Display quality variance between units
10Budget
Lenovo IdeaPad Gaming 3
Easy RAM and storage upgradesGreat value for priceSolid gaming performanceMediocre stock displayFragile disassembly experienceWeak battery life
Lenovo IdeaPad Gaming 3
Easy RAM and storage upgrades
Great value for price
Solid gaming performance
Mediocre stock display
Fragile disassembly experience
Weak battery life
You are here
31Premium
Asus ROG Strix Scar 15
Strong gaming and CPU/GPU performanceExcellent keyboard feelGood sound qualityHigh CPU/GPU temperatures under loadKeystone dongle criticized as gimmicky or invasiveSoftware and driver bugs
Asus ROG Strix Scar 15
Strong gaming and CPU/GPU performance
Excellent keyboard feel
Good sound quality
High CPU/GPU temperatures under load
Keystone dongle criticized as gimmicky or invasive
Software and driver bugs

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Gaming performance and CPU/GPU power consistently impress owners. Multiple owners describe the Scar 15 as a 'beast,' 'monster,' or 'kicking butt' laptop, citing strong Cinebench scores, high frame rates in demanding titles, and the newer MUX switch plus improved thermal compound giving a noticeable performance bump over prior-year models. Several highlight it handling 3D software, video editing, and AAA gaming at high settings without issue.

Heat and fan noise are the most frequently repeated frustrations. Owners report CPU temperatures spiking into the 90s Celsius under load, occasionally causing throttling well below advertised turbo speeds. Fan noise is described as loud enough to drown out other devices and annoy people nearby, with some resorting to cooling pads or elevating the laptop off the desk to help thermals, though results vary by unit and settings.

The keyboard and screen draw praise, but extras like the keystone and missing webcam are polarizing. Several users call the keyboard's feel excellent and a major draw, while the QHD/high-refresh panel is well regarded, though one owner reported bad screen bleed on two separate units. The keystone dongle is seen by some as gimmicky or privacy-invasive, phoning home to Asus, while the absence of a webcam and fingerprint scanner is repeatedly flagged as odd for a high-end machine.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?