Xiaomi Redmi 5From real comments

Verdict distilled from 20 mentions across 11 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment56%
PROS 56%
CONS 44%

Rank based on 20 mentions across 11 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want a fast, good-looking budget phone with a responsive fingerprint scanner
  • You value long-term reliability, since some owners still see decent performance after years of use
  • You're fine skipping NFC and just need solid everyday performance for the price

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You need contactless or NFC payments, since the Redmi 5 doesn't support it
  • You care about camera quality and screen resolution, as reviewers found both underwhelming
  • You want a modern, more powerful chipset instead of the dated Snapdragon 400/625-series

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choiceBest value
1Budget
Massive 7000mAh BatteryAffordable / Good ValuePremium Design for the PriceWeak CameraNo eSIM SupportShared SIM/SD Card Slot
Massive 7000mAh Battery
Affordable / Good Value
Premium Design for the Price
Weak Camera
No eSIM Support
Shared SIM/SD Card Slot
2Budget
Battery LifeValue For MoneyGaming PerformanceAverage CameraOverheatingRising Variant Pricing
Battery Life
Value For Money
Gaming Performance
Average Camera
Overheating
Rising Variant Pricing
3Budget
Strong battery life
Strong battery life
4Budget
Exceptional price-to-performance valueLarge battery with good screen featuresAds can be disabled easilyBaked-in MIUI ads and bloatwareLong-term hardware reliability concernsBattery drain issues reported by some users
Exceptional price-to-performance value
Large battery with good screen features
Ads can be disabled easily
Baked-in MIUI ads and bloatware
Long-term hardware reliability concerns
Battery drain issues reported by some users
5Budget
Great value for the priceReliable, smooth everyday performanceGood fit for basic or backup phone useDisappointing camera qualityRAM limitations on lower-end configurationBulkier, thicker design
Great value for the price
Reliable, smooth everyday performance
Good fit for basic or backup phone use
Disappointing camera quality
RAM limitations on lower-end configuration
Bulkier, thicker design
6Budget
AMOLED 120Hz DisplayExcellent Value for MoneyComplete Feature Set for the PriceInconsistent Night Mode Camera QualitySoftware Quirks and BugsBattery Degradation Over Time
AMOLED 120Hz Display
Excellent Value for Money
Complete Feature Set for the Price
Inconsistent Night Mode Camera Quality
Software Quirks and Bugs
Battery Degradation Over Time
7Budget
Excellent battery lifeStrong camera qualityGreat value for moneyInconsistent camera quality over time or vs rivalsLong-term reliability issuesPerformance decline after updates
Excellent battery life
Strong camera quality
Great value for money
Inconsistent camera quality over time or vs rivals
Long-term reliability issues
Performance decline after updates
8Budget
Huge battery lifeExceptional value for moneySharp Full HD+ displayNoticeable lag and stutterWeak camera systemReliability failures reported by some users
Huge battery life
Exceptional value for money
Sharp Full HD+ display
Noticeable lag and stutter
Weak camera system
Reliability failures reported by some users
9Budget
iPhone-like designFast 33W SuperVOOC chargingGood value for priceOutdated front camera and notchUnderpowered chipsetFalling behind on specs vs competitors
iPhone-like design
Fast 33W SuperVOOC charging
Good value for price
Outdated front camera and notch
Underpowered chipset
Falling behind on specs vs competitors
10Budget
Eye-friendly NXTPAPER displayGood for minimalist/reading useLong battery life in ink/B&W modeNot suited for gaming or heavy tasksLag and glitching in normal useLimited availability by region
Eye-friendly NXTPAPER display
Good for minimalist/reading use
Long battery life in ink/B&W mode
Not suited for gaming or heavy tasks
Lag and glitching in normal use
Limited availability by region
You are here
31Budget
Xiaomi Redmi 5
Fast, Smooth PerformanceGreat Value for MoneyFast Fingerprint ScannerWeak Camera & Low-Res DisplayOutdated ChipsetBattery Degrades Over Time
Xiaomi Redmi 5
Fast, Smooth Performance
Great Value for Money
Fast Fingerprint Scanner
Weak Camera & Low-Res Display
Outdated Chipset
Battery Degrades Over Time

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

A fast, good-value budget phone that impresses out of the box. Owners consistently describe the Redmi 5 as smooth and fast compared to previous devices, with an incredibly quick fingerprint scanner and stable MIUI 9.5 software. One user upgrading from an ASUS phone said data and Wi-Fi worked flawlessly and battery lasted a full day using about 30 percent charge. Reviewers call it good-looking with best-in-class value for money, and the Global variant comes with Google Play preinstalled, making setup painless for everyday use straight out of the box.

Camera and display specs feel behind the times. Multiple commenters note the camera hasn't meaningfully improved over older Redmi models, with one pointing out Xiaomi seemed to reuse the same Snapdragon 625 chipset without upgrading the sensor. Photos are also described as less wide than a rival ASUS phone. Another user, otherwise happy, singled out the 720 pixel resolution as disappointing given the phone's larger 18:9 screen, wishing for a sharper panel to match the size.

Missing NFC and long-term wear are real drawbacks. The absence of NFC for contactless payment is called a major turn-off by one reviewer, even though they rated everything else about the price-to-feature ratio as excellent. A three-year Redmi 5 Plus owner reported performance held steady but battery quality slipped over time. Another user experienced lag, internal rattling, and an unresponsive screen during gaming, while a separate commenter flagged GPS, Wi-Fi and charging problems specific to the Plus variant.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?