Withings Move ECGFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 19 mentions across 12 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment35%
PROS 35%
CONS 65%

Rank based on 19 mentions across 12 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want a simple, affordable analog watch with an occasional ECG check
  • You don't need a screen, GPS, or many smartwatch features
  • You value long battery life over recharging

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You need accurate step/activity tracking
  • You want continuous heart rate monitoring without pressing fingers
  • You expect responsive customer support for warranty issues

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Mid
Always-on displayMeaningful upgrade from older Apple WatchesSolid battery life for an always-on watchNot worth upgrading from Series 4Feels fragile without a caseNeeds nightly charging with always-on enabled
Always-on display
Meaningful upgrade from older Apple Watches
Solid battery life for an always-on watch
Not worth upgrading from Series 4
Feels fragile without a case
Needs nightly charging with always-on enabled
2Mid
Impressive Battery LifeVersatile Fitness Tracking FeaturesGorgeous AMOLED DisplayPrice ConcernsScreen Smudging and ScratchesIssues with Body Composition Measurement
Impressive Battery Life
Versatile Fitness Tracking Features
Gorgeous AMOLED Display
Price Concerns
Screen Smudging and Scratches
Issues with Body Composition Measurement
Best value
3Mid
Excellent Value for PriceGood Heart Rate TrackingLong Battery LifeInconsistent Heart Rate TrackingLimited Storage CapacitySoftware Bugs and Glitches
Excellent Value for Price
Good Heart Rate Tracking
Long Battery Life
Inconsistent Heart Rate Tracking
Limited Storage Capacity
Software Bugs and Glitches
4Budget
Impressive Battery LifeGreat Price-to-Quality RatioLightweight and Comfortable DesignLimited Storage CapacityInaccurate Sleep TrackingFragile Screen
Impressive Battery Life
Great Price-to-Quality Ratio
Lightweight and Comfortable Design
Limited Storage Capacity
Inaccurate Sleep Tracking
Fragile Screen
5Budget
Long Battery LifeAccurate Heart Rate MonitoringBuilt-in Alexa FunctionalityBattery Life DiscrepanciesInaccurate Tracking for Some ActivitiesStrap Durability Issues
Long Battery Life
Accurate Heart Rate Monitoring
Built-in Alexa Functionality
Battery Life Discrepancies
Inaccurate Tracking for Some Activities
Strap Durability Issues
6Mid
Long Battery LifeGood GPS AccuracyHigh-Quality Heart Rate MonitoringScreen Gets Dirty EasilyPrice ConsiderationsLimited Smart Features
Long Battery Life
Good GPS Accuracy
High-Quality Heart Rate Monitoring
Screen Gets Dirty Easily
Price Considerations
Limited Smart Features
7Mid
Larger, brighter displayDurability over timeFull-screen keyboardMinor/iterative upgrade for recent ownersLearning curve for first-time usersLimited neutral aluminum colors
Larger, brighter display
Durability over time
Full-screen keyboard
Minor/iterative upgrade for recent owners
Learning curve for first-time users
Limited neutral aluminum colors
8Budget
Great value for moneySkipping premium features isn't missedEasy to use, beginner friendlyBattery life disappoints some usersDurability and water resistance concernsMissing always-on display bothers some
Great value for money
Skipping premium features isn't missed
Easy to use, beginner friendly
Battery life disappoints some users
Durability and water resistance concerns
Missing always-on display bothers some
9Budget
Great value for priceNot missing high-end featuresStrong battery lifeNo always-on displayScreen fragility and crackingNo fast charging
Great value for price
Not missing high-end features
Strong battery life
No always-on display
Screen fragility and cracking
No fast charging
10Premium
Thinner, lighter designFast charging fits daily routinesMeaningful upgrade for long-term ownersBattery life limitationsIncremental yearly changesHeart rate accuracy issues during workouts
Thinner, lighter design
Fast charging fits daily routines
Meaningful upgrade for long-term owners
Battery life limitations
Incremental yearly changes
Heart rate accuracy issues during workouts
You are here
31Mid
Withings Move ECG
Useful ECG for heart monitoringColor optionsGood value for ECG-only needsDull design and missing analog detailsNo displayNo optical heart rate sensor
Withings Move ECG
Useful ECG for heart monitoring
Color options
Good value for ECG-only needs
Dull design and missing analog details
No display
No optical heart rate sensor

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

The ECG feature is the standout, praised for helping track heart conditions during exercise. Multiple commenters bought the Move ECG specifically to monitor tachycardia or arrhythmia, valuing that a doctor could review data captured during sport. One buyer confirmed the ECG function 'works fine' despite other issues. However, a cardiology-minded commenter cautions that a single-lead wrist ECG only offers one limited view of the heart and isn't a substitute for a full clinical 12-lead reading.

Design choices split opinion between simplicity and missing features. Some like the affordable price for ECG-only functionality without 'fancy smartwatch functions,' and enjoy the available color options. Others complain Withings 'went backwards' by dropping the display from earlier models, calling the watch dull-looking, criticizing the lack of a second hand for analog purists, and noting the face doesn't glow in the dark, making it hard to read at night.

Battery replacement is easy, but activity tracking and support draw complaints. Users appreciate that battery replacement can be done at home rather than mailing the watch back, with battery life reported around 12 months. But one buyer found step counts under-reported by about 20% and other activity types ignored entirely. Separate complaints describe unresponsive customer support and denied warranty claims on a related Withings product, raising concerns about post-purchase service.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?