Withings BPM CoreFrom real comments

Name: Withings BPM Core
Rating: 2.2 (16 reviews)

Verdict distilled from 16 mentions across 10 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment27%

PROS 27%

CONS 73%

Rank based on 16 mentions across 10 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

You want ECG and stethoscope features alongside blood pressure tracking
You're monitoring a known heart condition and value trend data over time
You have a slim arm that fits the cuff comfortably

What users love

Useful for existing heart condition monitoring0 mentions

Widely praised

Helps catch cardiac issues doctors miss0 mentions

Strongly positive

ECG and stethoscope features appeal to buyers0 mentions

Generally positive

Skip this if...

You need clinically consistent, doctor-office-accurate readings
You have muscular arms or need a right-hand-friendly design as a left-hander
You rely on strong customer support if something goes wrong

What users complain about

Inconsistent or inaccurate readingsNotable0 mentions

Strongly criticized

Difficult cuff fit for muscular or left-handed arms0 mentions

Frequently criticized

Requires undressing for skin contact0 mentions

Generally negative

Unresolved error codes on older units0 mentions

Frequently criticized

Multi-user account setup is troublesome0 mentions

Generally negative

Outdated micro-USB port0 mentions

Generally negative

Poor customer support0 mentions

Frequently criticized

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice

1Mid

Polar OH1

More comfortable than chest strapsGood for swimming with workaroundsStrong accuracy vs ECG/chest strapsInaccurate during arm-flexing exercisesBattery life concernsSyncing/recording confusion with third-party watches

Polar OH1

More comfortable than chest straps

Good for swimming with workarounds

Strong accuracy vs ECG/chest straps

Inaccurate during arm-flexing exercises

Battery life concerns

Syncing/recording confusion with third-party watches

2Premium

Garmin HRM 600

Rechargeable & washable strapStandalone activity recording without a watchEasy detachable podPremium pricingRechargeable battery drawbacksDistance and pace accuracy problems

Garmin HRM 600

Rechargeable & washable strap

Standalone activity recording without a watch

Easy detachable pod

Premium pricing

Rechargeable battery drawbacks

Distance and pace accuracy problems

3Mid

Polar Verity Sense

Chest-Strap-Free ComfortReliable Heart Rate AccuracyDual Bluetooth/ANT+ ConnectivityInaccurate Swim Distance TrackingConfusing Mode Selection and Connectivity IssuesGarmin Connect Sync Issues

Polar Verity Sense

Chest-Strap-Free Comfort

Reliable Heart Rate Accuracy

Dual Bluetooth/ANT+ Connectivity

Inaccurate Swim Distance Tracking

Confusing Mode Selection and Connectivity Issues

Garmin Connect Sync Issues

4Mid

Wahoo TICKR Fit

Long-term reliabilityReliable for heart conditionsGood for cold/dry conditionsPlacement affects accuracyStrap durability issuesDevice failure requiring warranty replacement

Wahoo TICKR Fit

Long-term reliability

Reliable for heart conditions

Good for cold/dry conditions

Placement affects accuracy

Strap durability issues

Device failure requiring warranty replacement

Best value

5Mid

Polar H10

Excellent accuracyWide device compatibilityLong-term reliability for some usersBluetooth connectivity dropoutsConfusing app setupBattery management hassles

Polar H10

Excellent accuracy

Wide device compatibility

Long-term reliability for some users

Bluetooth connectivity dropouts

Confusing app setup

Battery management hassles

6Budget

Polar H9

Accurate Heart Rate ReadingsAffordable PriceBroad Device CompatibilityNeeds Moistening for Reliable ContactApp Connectivity IssuesLimited Strap Sizing

Polar H9

Accurate Heart Rate Readings

Affordable Price

Broad Device Compatibility

Needs Moistening for Reliable Contact

App Connectivity Issues

Limited Strap Sizing

7Premium

Withings BeamO

Fits well into the Withings ecosystemSleek, futuristic designEasy to useHigh cost and subscription feesPoor customer supportUnverified sensor accuracy

Withings BeamO

Fits well into the Withings ecosystem

Sleek, futuristic design

Easy to use

High cost and subscription fees

Poor customer support

Unverified sensor accuracy

8Mid

Bose SoundSport Pulse

Good sound qualityAccurate heart rate sensorResponsive customer support replacementsFragile clothing clipBattery life and charging issuesIntrusive voice prompts

Bose SoundSport Pulse

Good sound quality

Accurate heart rate sensor

Responsive customer support replacements

Fragile clothing clip

Battery life and charging issues

Intrusive voice prompts

9Mid

Wahoo TICKR

Strong accuracy when working properlyDurable for some long-term usersGood value with cheap replacement strapsReliability degrades over timeErratic or wrong readings reportedNeeds skin moisture to maintain signal

Wahoo TICKR

Strong accuracy when working properly

Durable for some long-term users

Good value with cheap replacement straps

Reliability degrades over time

Erratic or wrong readings reported

Needs skin moisture to maintain signal

10Mid

Polar H7

Effective Once Paired CorrectlyAccurate Heart Rate ReadingsCompatible With Polar Beat AppBattery Compartment Groove Strips EasilyDifficult Battery Replacement Requires ToolsDevice Failures After Short Use

Polar H7

Effective Once Paired Correctly

Accurate Heart Rate Readings

Compatible With Polar Beat App

Battery Compartment Groove Strips Easily

Difficult Battery Replacement Requires Tools

Device Failures After Short Use

You are here

14Premium

Withings BPM Core

Useful for existing heart condition monitoringECG and stethoscope features appeal to buyersHelps catch cardiac issues doctors missInconsistent or inaccurate readingsDifficult cuff fit for muscular or left-handed armsMulti-user account setup is troublesome

Withings BPM Core

Useful for existing heart condition monitoring

ECG and stethoscope features appeal to buyers

Helps catch cardiac issues doctors miss

Inconsistent or inaccurate readings

Difficult cuff fit for muscular or left-handed arms

Multi-user account setup is troublesome

Battery life
1. Wahoo TICKR Fitarrow_downward1
2. Polar OH1arrow_downward2
3. Polar H10arrow_downward4
App confusion
1. Polar H7arrow_downward2
2. Polar H10arrow_downward5
Price
1. Bose SoundSport Pulsearrow_downward2
2. Garmin HRM 600arrow_downward5
Strap durability
1. Polar H10arrow_downward3
2. Wahoo TICKR Fitarrow_downward3
Device failure
1. Wahoo TICKR Fitarrow_downward1
2. Polar H7arrow_downward4
Good value
1. Wahoo TICKRarrow_upward3
2. Polar H10arrow_upward2

Overall Impression

Readings can be frustratingly inconsistent from one measurement to the next. Multiple users report large swings in results within minutes of each other or compared to trusted equipment. One user's triple measurement varied by double digits within 10 minutes, another compared it to a hospital vitals monitor and got dangerously lower readings, and a third had a local clinic confirm the device's numbers were wrong. This undermines confidence in using it for real medical decisions.

Cuff fit and ergonomics frustrate some users. One reviewer with defined triceps called fitting the cuff a nightmare, with persistent air pockets causing errors due to the semi-solid cuff design. A left-handed user noted the device doesn't work well on the right side, making it hard to attach with a non-dominant hand, and also disliked needing to undress for skin contact, unlike their previous Omron cuff.

Cardiac monitoring features earn praise from users with real heart conditions. One user with bradycardia and high blood pressure says the device, alongside other trackers, helped confirm a diagnosis that regular doctor visits missed due to symptoms not appearing during office visits. Another purchased it after a heart failure diagnosis specifically seeking this kind of home monitoring, and a third ordered one after a concerning headache and elevated blood pressure reading.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?

monitor_heartUseful for existing heart condition monitoring

2 mentions

Widely praised

Users cite recent heart failure diagnoses and concerning BP spikes as reasons for buying the device to keep a closer eye on their health at home.

@EssexCountyPhoto

Cheers doc! I'm 48, usually ok-ish fitness and recently experienced a random \"thunderclap\" headache. \nBP was still 150/104 the next morning.\nA week ago, still hurts.\nI've ordered one of those to keep an eye on things...

smart_display

December 1, 2024

@bederhajali

Been looking something to help me with recent diagnosis of heart failure. Thanks the video. What I've been looking for

smart_display

September 17, 2020

favoriteHelps catch cardiac issues doctors miss

1 mentions

Strongly positive

One user says the device, alongside other trackers, detected bradycardia as low as 39 bpm that led to a formal diagnosis, since symptoms didn't appear during in-office visits. This kind of continuous home monitoring filled a real gap in care.

@J53718

I love this device on the 3X setting. I suffer from bradycardia and high blood pressure and use this device (Kardia Mobile 6L)(Withings BPM) (FITBIT Versa 2), all of which detect bradycardia as low as 39 bpm on average 46 bpm. My primary physician referred me to cardiologist who stated I indeed have Bradycardia. This device along with other devices were paramount in detecting what normal visits to my physician did not. As we all know sometimes symptoms do not always occur when you need them to such as during a visit to your physicians office. White coat syndrome.

smart_display

April 19, 2021

hearingECG and stethoscope features appeal to buyers

1 mentions

Generally positive

Buyers were drawn to the device specifically for its combination of blood pressure, ECG, and digital stethoscope capabilities as part of a broader health monitoring decision.

@PatrickRambles

Thanks for this review, doc. Turning 40 and have been re-evaluating my lifestyle and therefore also want to start seriously monitoring. This has helped me decide on the Core.

smart_display

November 20, 2021

warningInconsistent or inaccurate readingsNotable

5 mentions

Strongly criticized

Multiple users report large swings between repeated measurements and readings that diverge sharply from hospital or clinic equipment, with one clinic confirming the readings were wrong. This is the most frequently cited and serious complaint.

@Nizovtsev

We bought this device — why does it work like this?\nFor example: a single measurement shows 133/86, then after 5 minutes I do a triple measurement and get a more accurate result 115/92. So tell me, how am I supposed to determine my blood pressure?\nOn another day it was 141/86, after five minutes 128/95, and another five minutes later 122/88.\nTell me, is this normal behavior for the device?

smart_display

January 12, 2026

@nrage76

I just purchased this thing and its garbage, readings are way off my normal range is about 117/76......this device said i was in the 160/92 range. Local medical clinic confirmed the withing reads were crap

smart_display

November 20, 2025

@VladimirRužić

Complete and utter garbage. Threw it away in less than 7 days of usage, don't bother buying their BP machine. Its measurements are not precise. I tested it while connected to a real hospital vitals monitor and it showed way lower BP than I realistically had which is quite dangerous for someone who checks up their health at home. \n\nErgonomically it is a nightmare. It was obviously designed by DIE hire. If you are at least a bit muscular ie. if you have defined triceps good luck fitting the device on yourself. No matter what you do there will be a pocket of air and device's cannot fill the gap resulting in error. So you will have a quite frustrating time fitting this garbage on your arm. This issue could be easily solvable if the cuff was not made semi-solid, but like I already stated this was not built with health in mind but for the sake of bling and nice application. The stethoscope fell off by itself during the night (the device was on the shelf nobody touched it)... \n\nOverall quality wise I felt like I bought 20$ Temu/Aliexpress device, but for 10x of the price.

smart_display

November 13, 2024

@blackshw1

Have they fixed the 302 error that occurred with the old units which they never were able to explain or fix? I loved my Withings but went elsewhere due to the inability to fix or explain the issue which I and many others experienced.

smart_display

November 17, 2022

accessibility_newDifficult cuff fit for muscular or left-handed arms

2 mentions

Frequently criticized

A user with defined triceps struggled to get a proper seal due to air pockets from the semi-solid cuff, and a left-handed user found it hard to attach with their non-dominant hand since it favors the left arm.

@deeyon6671

I bought this as my GP has been asking for 4 days of readings and my OMRON cuff appears unable to pair with my new iPhone (16 pro max). My mother is in heart failure with Mitral valve failure and pulmonary and kidney failure. She’s 82 and has been really fit until recently. Studies show I may be more at risk (& certainly not as fit as she has been), so I wanted to make sure I could closely monitor myself. The NHS is becoming harder to get near in terms of even a general chat with the doctor so I am feeling vulnerable and felt a need to invest in myself in order to raise any alarm that is or becomes necessary. I do wish this worked on the right side though as I left hander it’s hard to get in easily with my non dominant hand. Plus I have to undress to get the skin to cuff contact - both of these my OMRON didn’t need .

smart_display

October 2, 2025

@VladimirRužić

smart_display

November 13, 2024

checkroomRequires undressing for skin contact

1 mentions

Generally negative

Unlike some competing cuffs, this device needs direct skin contact, meaning users must undress the arm to take a reading, which one user found less convenient than their previous Omron.

@deeyon6671

smart_display

October 2, 2025

errorUnresolved error codes on older units

1 mentions

Frequently criticized

A commenter asks whether Withings ever fixed a 302 error that affected older units and was never explained or resolved, leading them to switch brands.

@blackshw1

smart_display

November 17, 2022

groupMulti-user account setup is troublesome

1 mentions

Generally negative

A new buyer reports having a hard time adding different users or accounts to the device.

@athenaenergyshine7616

I just bought this it is great but I am having a hell of a time adding different users or account.have you tried it with different users and account

smart_display

April 5, 2026

usbOutdated micro-USB port

1 mentions

Generally negative

A user criticizes the device's size and its use of micro-USB instead of the more modern USB-C connector.

@abdulkreemalsultan134

The bad thing is the size and the micro usb they should use type C

smart_display

November 1, 2025

support_agentPoor customer support

1 mentions

Frequently criticized

A commenter describes customer support as horrible, saying getting answers to questions is difficult.

@joeinge4808

Customer support is horrible - if you have any questions — good luck.

smart_display

July 10, 2025

Withings BPM Corechat_bubble_outlineFrom real comments

thumb_up_off_altBuy this if...

What users lovefavorite_border

thumb_down_off_altSkip this if...

What users complain aboutheart_broken

Compare in seconds

Who wins on what

Battery life

App confusion

Price

Strap durability

Device failure

Good value

auto_awesomeOverall Impression

Withings BPM CoreFrom real comments

Buy this if...

What users love

Skip this if...

What users complain about

Overall Impression