Withings Body CardioFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 34 mentions across 11 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment21%
PROS 21%
CONS 79%

Rank based on 34 mentions across 11 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want detailed body composition metrics like body fat and heart health data
  • You're comfortable troubleshooting Wi-Fi/Bluetooth setup issues
  • You value accuracy comparable to professional body measurements

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You want a simple, no-fuss weight-only scale
  • You're not willing to risk battery failure after about a year with limited warranty support
  • You expect responsive customer service if something breaks

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choice
1Premium
Withings U-Scan
Innovative concept
Withings U-Scan
Innovative concept
2Premium
Wahoo KICKR ROLLR
Fast, hassle-free setupGreat for multi-bike or multi-rider householdsNatural road-like ride feelRequires a separate external power meterRear tire wearStress on front wheel and fork
Wahoo KICKR ROLLR
Fast, hassle-free setup
Great for multi-bike or multi-rider households
Natural road-like ride feel
Requires a separate external power meter
Rear tire wear
Stress on front wheel and fork
3Premium
Wahoo KICKR BIKE
Responsive customer serviceRealistic, stable ride feelZero-faff convenienceUnit failures and reliability concernsCreaking and grinding noisesHigh price
Wahoo KICKR BIKE
Responsive customer service
Realistic, stable ride feel
Zero-faff convenience
Unit failures and reliability concerns
Creaking and grinding noises
High price
4Premium
Wahoo KICKR CLIMB
Realistic muscle engagement on climbsAdds immersion and fun to indoor ridingImproved comfort on long ridesBelt failure and drop riskNoticeable lag between gradient change and movementHigh price relative to perceived necessity
Wahoo KICKR CLIMB
Realistic muscle engagement on climbs
Adds immersion and fun to indoor riding
Improved comfort on long rides
Belt failure and drop risk
Noticeable lag between gradient change and movement
High price relative to perceived necessity
5Mid
Wahoo KICKR CORE
Virtual shifting via Zwift Cog/ClickLong-term reliability for some ownersVery quiet operationPower accuracy discrepanciesRecurring ticking or ringing noiseWiFi/Bridge connectivity issues
Wahoo KICKR CORE
Virtual shifting via Zwift Cog/Click
Long-term reliability for some owners
Very quiet operation
Power accuracy discrepancies
Recurring ticking or ringing noise
WiFi/Bridge connectivity issues
6Premium
Withings U-Scan Nutrio
Innovative conceptPotential for future improvementFits broader smart-home health trendHigh price for limited insightsDoubts about Withings' track recordCheaper alternatives exist
Withings U-Scan Nutrio
Innovative concept
Potential for future improvement
Fits broader smart-home health trend
High price for limited insights
Doubts about Withings' track record
Cheaper alternatives exist
7Budget
Casio CDP-S160
Good tone quality for beginnersAffordable price for beginnersBattery-powered portabilityUneven black/white key downweightCriticism of short/poor key actionFragile 1/8-inch output jack
Casio CDP-S160
Good tone quality for beginners
Affordable price for beginners
Battery-powered portability
Uneven black/white key downweight
Criticism of short/poor key action
Fragile 1/8-inch output jack
8Premium
Wahoo KICKR
Smooth, reliable long-term performanceWiFi bridge and firmware convenienceVirtual shifting via Zwift CogBearing and flywheel failures causing noisePower accuracy inconsistenciesVibration and stability problems on bikes
Wahoo KICKR
Smooth, reliable long-term performance
WiFi bridge and firmware convenience
Virtual shifting via Zwift Cog
Bearing and flywheel failures causing noise
Power accuracy inconsistencies
Vibration and stability problems on bikes
9Mid
Withings Body+
Fast, seamless setup for someReliable for many long-term usersEcosystem integration with other Withings devicesFrequent setup and pairing failuresInaccurate or inconsistent body fat readingsLong-term connectivity breakdowns
Withings Body+
Fast, seamless setup for some
Reliable for many long-term users
Ecosystem integration with other Withings devices
Frequent setup and pairing failures
Inaccurate or inconsistent body fat readings
Long-term connectivity breakdowns
10Premium
Wahoo KICKR Bike Shift
Quiet operationImproved ride feel over older trainersResponsive customer serviceCreaking, grinding and clanking noisesHigh price relative to valueUnnatural pedaling/resistance feel
Wahoo KICKR Bike Shift
Quiet operation
Improved ride feel over older trainers
Responsive customer service
Creaking, grinding and clanking noises
High price relative to value
Unnatural pedaling/resistance feel
You are here
14Premium
Withings Body Cardio
Detailed health metricsAccurate measurementsFeature-rich appBattery fails after about a yearDifficult setup and connectivitySetup/factory-reset loop bugs
Withings Body Cardio
Detailed health metrics
Accurate measurements
Feature-rich app
Battery fails after about a year
Difficult setup and connectivity
Setup/factory-reset loop bugs

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Accuracy and features impress users who get the scale working reliably. Multiple commenters found the Body Cardio's readings spot-on, with one comparing results favorably to nutritionist-measured body composition numbers. Others called it 'the most amazing scale' and praised the app's regular updates and depth of data, including pulse wave velocity and heart health metrics, though a few noted these advanced readings could be confusing or later removed via software update.

Setup and connectivity frustrate a large share of reviewers. Many users describe difficulty connecting to Wi-Fi or the phone app, citing wasted hours, factory-reset loops, and a persistent 'Hello' setup loop. Some resolved issues by following troubleshooting tips or waiting it out, while others gave up entirely, comparing the experience unfavorably to simpler competitors like Fitbit or Renpho and calling setup 'impossible' given the price.

Battery failure after about a year is a widespread complaint. Numerous owners report the rechargeable battery stops charging roughly a year in, often just after the one-year warranty expires, rendering the scale unusable since the battery isn't designed to be replaced. Several attempted DIY fixes—resoldering, swapping AA batteries, or replacing the internal cell—with mixed success, while customer service was repeatedly described as unhelpful in resolving the issue.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?