Edifier S1000 MKIIFrom real comments

Verdict distilled from 5 mentions across 3 aspects in comments under product review videos.

Positive sentiment75%
PROS 75%
CONS 25%

Rank based on 5 mentions across 3 aspects

View the verdict as

Buy this if...

  • You want speakers repeatedly praised for excellent overall sound quality
  • You prioritize a strong low-mid range for music listening over extra sub-bass extension
  • You're upgrading from headphones to a proper powered speaker setup

What users love

Skip this if...

  • You're skeptical about whether the 120W RMS rating matches real-world power delivery
  • You need confirmed compatibility with a turntable or preamp before buying
  • You need clear reassurance on room-size fit or harshness, which remain unanswered in user discussion

What users complain about

Compare in seconds

Based on user comments

Best choiceBest value
1Mid
Wharfedale Denton 85
Warm, non-fatiguing soundStrong bass without needing a subwooferExcellent build quality and finishCan be overwhelming at higher volumes in smaller roomsLess precise detail retrieval than pricier speakersPlacement-sensitive for best imaging
Wharfedale Denton 85
Warm, non-fatiguing sound
Strong bass without needing a subwoofer
Excellent build quality and finish
Can be overwhelming at higher volumes in smaller rooms
Less precise detail retrieval than pricier speakers
Placement-sensitive for best imaging
2
Yamaha NS-670
Wonderful, balanced soundEnduring build qualityGood cosmetic condition possibleUncertain resale pricingAge-related hesitancy to serviceScratchy potentiometers
Yamaha NS-670
Wonderful, balanced sound
Enduring build quality
Good cosmetic condition possible
Uncertain resale pricing
Age-related hesitancy to service
Scratchy potentiometers
3Budget
Polk Audio Signature S20
Amp compatibilityExcellent value for priceStrong bass response
Polk Audio Signature S20
Amp compatibility
Excellent value for price
Strong bass response
4Premium
Yamaha NS-600A
Wide, immersive soundstageBuild and finish qualityStrong brand loyalty and satisfactionAmplifier pairing uncertaintyHigh price relative to alternativesPlacement sensitivity required
Yamaha NS-600A
Wide, immersive soundstage
Build and finish quality
Strong brand loyalty and satisfaction
Amplifier pairing uncertainty
High price relative to alternatives
Placement sensitivity required
5Premium
Epos ES-7N
Big sound for its sizeArticulate midrangeLong-term owner satisfactionCheap build componentsHigh price relative to build
Epos ES-7N
Big sound for its size
Articulate midrange
Long-term owner satisfaction
Cheap build components
High price relative to build
6Budget
Wharfedale Diamond 8.1
Excellent ValueBalanced, Non-Fatiguing SoundLong-Term Durability
Wharfedale Diamond 8.1
Excellent Value
Balanced, Non-Fatiguing Sound
Long-Term Durability
7Mid
Wharfedale Evo 4.1
Well-implemented AMT tweeterDeep, punchy bass beyond expectationsSolid build quality and attractive cabinetNeeds a powerful amplifierYellow/gold AMT tweeter styling divides opinionBenefits from burn-in before sounding its best
Wharfedale Evo 4.1
Well-implemented AMT tweeter
Deep, punchy bass beyond expectations
Solid build quality and attractive cabinet
Needs a powerful amplifier
Yellow/gold AMT tweeter styling divides opinion
Benefits from burn-in before sounding its best
8Budget
Pioneer BS22
Exceptional value for moneyClear, detailed mids and vocalsSurprisingly strong bass outputRequires adequate amplification to shineCan sound boomy or bass-heavy without treatmentIsolated complaint about cheap construction and poor mids
Pioneer BS22
Exceptional value for money
Clear, detailed mids and vocals
Surprisingly strong bass output
Requires adequate amplification to shine
Can sound boomy or bass-heavy without treatment
Isolated complaint about cheap construction and poor mids
9Premium
Focal Sopra No1
Exceptional detail and resolution
Focal Sopra No1
Exceptional detail and resolution
10Mid
Polk Audio Signature S10
Fits Into a Larger Signature Series SystemDecent Sound QualityGreat for Small RoomsNeeds a Subwoofer to Fill a Room
Polk Audio Signature S10
Fits Into a Larger Signature Series System
Decent Sound Quality
Great for Small Rooms
Needs a Subwoofer to Fill a Room
You are here
31
Edifier S1000 MKII
Excellent Overall Sound QualityStrong Low-Mid Range for MusicQuestionable Power Rating
Edifier S1000 MKII
Excellent Overall Sound Quality
Strong Low-Mid Range for Music
Questionable Power Rating

Who wins on what

Ranked by what users actually praise

Overall Impression

Listeners consistently praised the S1000 MKII's sound quality across different comparison points. Multiple commenters highlighted strong sound performance: one called it 'absolutely brilliant,' another found it 'quite good' even while primarily using high-end B&W 800 D3 speakers with McIntosh amps, and a new owner felt the speakers fit the purpose of upgrading from headphones to real output, planning to test them with AC/DC tracks right after purchase.

Compared to the pricier S3000 MKII, the S1000 MKII was favored for music listening. One listener who owned both models preferred the S1000 MKII specifically for its low-mid range response, describing it as more enjoyable for general music listening. They noted the S3000 MKII instead offers a smiley-face sound profile with better sub-bass and treble detail but a comparatively weaker midrange, making the S1000 MKII the pick for midrange-focused listening.

Some practical uncertainties surfaced around specs and setup. One commenter expressed doubt about the speaker's 120W RMS rating, comparing it unfavorably to an older 75W speaker that produced stronger felt bass. Beyond that, several prospective buyers asked unanswered questions about room size suitability, turntable and preamp pairing, auto power-off behavior, and whether the rubber feet were removable, leaving these details unresolved in the discussion.

Outdated / Not-accurate data?